Where to start reading
Start with
The Refutation of All Heresies
Books by Hippolytus of Rome (1)
Biography
Hippolytus of Rome is one of the most learned voices of the early church and one of the hardest to pin down. He preached, expounded Scripture and wrote a huge attack on every heresy he knew. He was a presbyter of the Roman church who fell out so badly with two of its bishops that later historians called him the first antipope. Yet he died an exile in Sardinia, probably in its mines, beside the very bishop of Rome his party had opposed, and the church that buried them both now honours them on the same feast day. It is a story of truth held fiercely, a long quarrel, and a peace that came at the end.
A Greek voice in the Roman church
Almost nothing about his early life is certain. He was probably born around 170, though some put it a few years earlier, and nobody knows where. Even Eusebius and Jerome, who had read his books, could not say where he served. An old tradition makes him a disciple of Irenaeus of Lyons, and through Irenaeus a spiritual grandchild of Polycarp and of the apostle John. The ninth-century scholar Photios passes it on, and the editors of our translation treat it as settled; modern scholars are less sure. It is best received as cherished, unproven tradition.
What is clearer is the man in his prime. He seems to have been a presbyter, or elder, of the church at Rome in the years when Zephyrinus was its bishop (199–217), and he was known for his learning and eloquence. According to one old account, the young Origen heard him preach during a visit to Rome. He wrote on a remarkable range of subjects: commentaries on Daniel and on the Song of Songs, a treatise On Christ and the Antichrist from around 200, a chronicle of the world from creation down to the year 234, and works on church order. His Commentary on Daniel holds the earliest known reference to Christ’s birth being kept on 25 December. In the same book he warned against those who predicted that Christ’s return was close at hand.
The quarrel with the bishops
His conflict with the Roman bishops began over the doctrine of God. A teaching was spreading in Rome, brought by followers of one Noetus of Smyrna, that Father and Son are simply two names for one and the same divine person. Historians call this modalism. Its defenders meant to protect the oneness of God; Hippolytus believed it meant that the Father himself was born and suffered. He held instead to the Logos theology of earlier Greek writers such as Justin Martyr, which distinguished the Father from his Word, or Logos. In the ninth book of the Refutation he says that Bishop Zephyrinus tolerated the new teaching and was steered by his adviser Callistus. He says that he and his friends refused to give way, and that Callistus answered by calling them “Ditheists,” worshippers of two gods.
The second quarrel was over sin and forgiveness. When Callistus became bishop in 217, he received back into communion Christians who had committed grave sins such as adultery, and he was more lenient about the marriages of clergy. To Hippolytus, a strict moralist, this looked like the church surrendering its holiness. To Callistus’s supporters it was mercy to sinners in a church filling with new converts from paganism. Hippolytus himself records that Callistus appealed to the parable of the wheat and the tares and to Noah’s ark, which held clean and unclean animals alike.
What Hippolytus did next is disputed. The older view, still widely held, is that he let himself be chosen as a rival bishop of Rome and led a separate congregation through the time of Callistus and his successors Urban and Pontian. That is why he is often called the first antipope. Others think Rome then had no single bishop in the later sense, but a network of house-churches, and that Hippolytus led one of them, perhaps a Greek-speaking community gathered round a teacher like a school of philosophy. The sources do not settle it; we do not fully know how far he went.
Reading Book IX with open eyes
The quarrel survives only in Hippolytus’s own telling, and that telling is hostile. He describes Callistus as a slave who lost his master’s money and the deposits of widows, fled and threw himself into the sea, and was sent to the Sardinian mines after a disturbance in a synagogue. He then charges him with buying influence over a bishop he calls ignorant and greedy, and with opening a school that welcomed sinners for the sake of numbers. Some of it may be true, but it is the account of a bitter opponent, written after Callistus’s death, with no reply from the other side. The church remembers Callistus as a pope, and his side of the story is simply lost. Book IX is a precious window into the Roman church of the early third century. It is not a fair trial.
Hippolytus could be harsh, and he was sure he was right. Yet he believed that what God is and how God forgives were at stake, and he would not trade them for peace.
But none will refute these, save the Holy Spirit bequeathed unto the Church, which the Apostles, having in the first instance received, have transmitted to those who have rightly believed.
— Hippolytus, The Refutation of All Heresies, Book I
A labyrinth of heresies
The Refutation of All Heresies was written after 222, near the end of his life. It was planned in ten books. The first surveys the Greek philosophers; the second and third, now lost, dealt with Egyptian mysteries and Chaldean astrology; the fourth treats astrologers and magicians. Books V to IX then work through the Christian heresies one school at a time, and Book X sums up and sets out what the author himself believes.
His argument is simple and polemical: every heresy, he claims, is stolen not from Scripture but from pagan philosophy, mystery religion and astrology, dressed up in Christian words. Most were Gnostics, who taught that salvation comes through secret knowledge, often with long chains of heavenly powers between the true God and this world. They included the Naassenes and Ophites, Simon Magus, Valentinus, Basilides and Marcion. The reader need not master their systems. His family tree of errors is a polemicist’s case and should be read as one. But in building it he copied out a great deal of what his opponents actually wrote, and so preserved sayings of the philosopher Heraclitus, passages of Basilides, and much of the Greek of Irenaeus’s own work against the heresies.
Then the tone changes. Book X turns to what the author calls the doctrine of the truth: one God who made the world from nothing and made nothing evil, and the Word, born of a virgin, who lived through every stage of human life to be a pattern for all, and endured hunger, thirst and weariness:
He did not protest against His Passion, but became obedient unto death, and manifested His resurrection.
— Hippolytus, The Refutation of All Heresies, Book X
Exile in Sardinia
In 235, during the persecution under the emperor Maximinus Thrax, Hippolytus and Pontian, bishop of Rome, were exiled together to Sardinia, where they very likely died in the mines. The man whose book mocks Callistus for his years in the Sardinian mines ended his own life there. There, it seems, the long division ended. The two old opponents, sharing the same exile, appear to have made their peace; later accounts say Hippolytus urged his followers to return to unity with the church.
The evidence is quiet but telling. Under Pope Fabian the bodies of Pontian and Hippolytus were brought back to Rome, and a Roman record known as the Chronography of 354 says that they were buried on 13 August, probably in 236. Hippolytus was buried on the Via Tiburtina, his funeral led by one Justin the Confessor. The same document shows that by about 255 he was counted a martyr, and it gives him the rank of presbyter, not bishop. This strongly suggests he died at peace with the church he had once opposed. The later tale that he was dragged to death by wild horses grew from confusion with other men of the same name.
Be not therefore inflamed, O ye men, with enmity one towards another, nor hesitate to retrace with all speed your steps. For Christ is the God above all, and He has arranged to wash away sin from human beings, rendering regenerate the old man.
— Hippolytus, The Refutation of All Heresies, Book X
A statue and a lost manuscript
Writing in Greek, his name tangled with legends of other saints called Hippolytus, he was nearly forgotten in the West. Two discoveries brought him back. In 1551, during digging near the church of St Lawrence on the Via Tiburtina, a marble seated statue came to light. It had been heavily restored, but on its chair were carved a table for finding Easter and a list of writings matched to Hippolytus. An inscription of Pope Pius IV named it as Saint Hippolytus. Modern study has shown that the original figure was a woman, perhaps a personification of one of the sciences, so the monument’s purpose is debated again.
Then, in 1842, the Greek scholar Minoïdes Mynas brought from a monastery on Mount Athos a manuscript holding Books IV to X of a lost work against the heresies. Emmanuel Miller published it at Oxford in 1851 under the name of Origen. Book I had long been printed among Origen’s writings under the title Philosophumena. Most nineteenth-century scholars soon assigned the whole to Hippolytus, and controversialists on both sides of Protestant and Catholic debates about the papacy seized on it. Recent scholarship is more cautious, and many now treat the Refutation as the work of an unknown author, probably Roman. The same caution surrounds the Apostolic Tradition, a church order identified as his in the early twentieth century. Its attribution is now hotly contested.
Why read his book now
The book we publish is J. H. MacMahon’s translation from the Ante-Nicene Fathers (1886), with the editors’ introductory notice. It is long, and in places a slog: Books II and III are lost, Book IV is a catalogue of astrology and conjuring tricks, and its judgments are not gentle. But it is also a first-hand witness to the church of the early third century, written by someone who says he took part in the events he describes. It shows what Roman Christians argued about and why the doctrine of God mattered so much to them. And it ends with a warm invitation to faith.
Hippolytus is a strange companion: brilliant, stubborn, often unfair, and devoted to the truth as he saw it. His life warns how zeal for doctrine can harden into division; his death shows that divided Christians can still be brought home. His closing counsel still stands:
Do not devote your attention to the fallacies of artificial discourses, nor the vain promises of plagiarizing heretics, but to the venerable simplicity of unassuming truth.
— Hippolytus, The Refutation of All Heresies, Book X
Questions and Answers
Who was Hippolytus of Rome?
Hippolytus was a learned Greek-speaking presbyter of the church at Rome in the early third century, a preacher, biblical commentator and writer against heresy. He quarrelled bitterly with the Roman bishops of his day, was exiled to Sardinia with Bishop Pontian in 235, and died there; the church honours him as a saint and martyr.
When and where was Hippolytus born?
Nobody knows where he was born, and the date is uncertain; around 170 is commonly given, though some place it a few years earlier. Even Eusebius and Jerome, who had read his works, could not say where he served.
Was Hippolytus a disciple of Irenaeus?
An old tradition, passed on by the ninth-century scholar Photios and accepted by the nineteenth-century editors of the Ante-Nicene Fathers, makes him a disciple of Irenaeus of Lyons. Modern scholars regard the claim as doubtful, so it is best treated as tradition rather than established fact.
What did Hippolytus write?
He wrote on a wide range of subjects, including commentaries on Daniel and the Song of Songs, a treatise On Christ and the Antichrist, a chronicle of the world down to 234, and works on church order. His Commentary on Daniel contains the earliest known reference to Christ’s birth being kept on 25 December.
Why did Hippolytus clash with Zephyrinus and Callistus?
He accused them of tolerating or teaching modalism, the view that Father and Son are only two names for one divine person, and he held instead to the Logos theology that distinguished the Father from the Word. He also opposed Callistus for readmitting Christians who had committed grave sins and for relaxing rules about the marriages of clergy.
Why is Hippolytus called the first antipope?
The older and still common view is that he was chosen as a rival bishop of Rome and led a separate congregation through the time of Callistus, Urban and Pontian. Some modern scholars think Rome was then a network of house-churches without a single bishop in the later sense, so how far he set up a rival church remains disputed.
Is his account of Callistus reliable?
It should be read with caution. Book IX of the Refutation portrays Callistus as a dishonest former slave and a lax, scheming churchman, but it was written by a bitter opponent after Callistus’s death, and no reply from Callistus’s side survives.
How did Hippolytus die?
In 235, during the persecution under the emperor Maximinus Thrax, he and Bishop Pontian were exiled together to Sardinia, where they probably died in the mines. It appears the two were reconciled there; under Pope Fabian their bodies were brought back to Rome, and an early Roman record names Hippolytus a martyr with the rank of presbyter.
What is The Refutation of All Heresies?
It is a ten-book work arguing that each heresy of the early church, especially the Gnostic systems, was borrowed from pagan philosophy, mystery religion and astrology rather than Scripture; Books II and III are lost. We publish J. H. MacMahon’s 1886 Ante-Nicene Fathers translation, a polemical but first-hand witness to the Roman church of the early third century that ends with a warm appeal to all nations to know the true God.
Did Hippolytus really write the Refutation and the Apostolic Tradition?
Books IV to X of the Refutation were found on Mount Athos in 1842 and first published in 1851 under the name of Origen; nineteenth-century scholars mostly assigned the work to Hippolytus, but many today treat it as the work of an unknown, probably Roman, author. Whether the Apostolic Tradition, a church order containing the earliest known ordination ritual, is his is also hotly contested.