
Where to start reading
Start with
The Christian's Great Interest
Books by William Guthrie (1)
Biography
William Guthrie was a country minister in Ayrshire, in the west of Scotland, who spent twenty years preaching to farming families in a single parish. In his lifetime he published one book, mainly because someone else printed a garbled version of his sermons without asking him. That small book, The Christian’s Great Interest, has been reprinted ever since and translated into Dutch, French, German and Gaelic. It asks how a Christian can know that he truly belongs to Christ, and what to do if he is not sure. Its author knew that anxiety from the inside, loved his people, and lost his pulpit for his convictions.
The heir of Pitforthy
Guthrie was born in 1620 at Pitforthy, near Brechin in Forfarshire (Angus), in the north-east of Scotland. His father was the laird, the landowner, of Pitforthy, and William was the eldest of eight children. Three of his brothers also became ministers.
As heir to the estate he went to the University of St Andrews, where his studies were directed by his cousin James Guthrie, then a regent, or tutor, in philosophy, a man of firm principle who would one day die for it. William graduated Master of Arts on 5 June 1638, the year Scotland signed the National Covenant, a solemn pledge to defend the Reformed faith and the Presbyterian government of the church against the changes Charles I was forcing on it. Those who held to it came to be called Covenanters.
Awakened under Rutherford
He stayed at St Andrews to study divinity under Samuel Rutherford, whose letters are still read for their longing love for Christ. According to the memoir prefixed to later editions of his book, Rutherford’s preaching changed him. Though always respectable and religious, the memoir says, he was thrown into “a fearful state of agitation,” seeing how far he stood from holiness and how justly he stood condemned. The terror gave way to the comfort of the gospel, and he resolved to give his whole life to Christ’s service.
He showed it by making over Pitforthy to one of his brothers. He was licensed to preach by the presbytery of St Andrews in August 1642, at twenty-two, and became tutor to Lord Mauchline, eldest son of the Earl of Loudoun, then Lord Chancellor of Scotland. That early struggle mattered. The memoir says he could sympathise with the fearful because he had himself known “a most anxious apprehension for the fate of his own soul,” and his book reads like the work of a man who had once needed it.
The minister of Fenwick
While in the Loudoun household, Guthrie preached at Galston in Ayrshire on a day of preparation before the Lord’s Supper. Some people from Fenwick, a parish newly carved out of the old parish of Kilmarnock, heard him and urged their neighbours to call him. The call was unanimous, though the parish’s patron, Lord Boyd, a strong loyalist, opposed it. The presbytery of Irvine ordained him at Fenwick on 7 November 1644, its first minister. In August 1645 he married Agnes Campbell, daughter of David Campbell of Skeldon. They had six children, but only two daughters outlived their parents.
The memoir describes Fenwick as a neglected parish where few families prayed together, and credits his ministry with a great change: family worship became common, and people came from Glasgow, Hamilton, Lanark and farther, so many that much of the crowd listened from outside. That account comes from admirers, but older sources agree that his church was crowded and his visiting fruitful. His contemporary John Livingstone is quoted as saying that his people turned the cornfield of his glebe, the land that went with the manse, into “a little town,” each building a house there so as to live under his ministry.
He was not a solemn figure. His health needed outdoor exercise, and he was a keen angler and fowler, a hunter of game birds. A ready wit and unconventional dress earned him the name “the fool of Fenwick,” meaning something like the jester, and it even appeared on title pages of his sermons. The memoir and John Howie’s eighteenth-century Biographia Scoticana say he used his rambles by the river and over the fields to reach people who would never come to church, talking with them as a sportsman before they knew he was their minister. One story, as Howie tells it, concerns a man who went fowling every Sunday because the Sabbath was his luckiest day and earned him half a crown. Guthrie offered him the same half crown to come to church instead. The man came, kept coming, and in time became an elder.
He declined calls to Renfrew, Linlithgow, Stirling, Glasgow and Edinburgh, and stayed with his country parish.
I have likewise studied brevity in every thing, so far as I conceived it to be consistent with plainness and perspicuity; knowing that the persons to whom I address myself, have neither much money to spend upon books, nor much time to spare upon reading.
— William Guthrie, The Christian’s Great Interest, To the Reader
His parish years were among the most turbulent in Scottish history. The General Assembly made him an army chaplain, and he was present at the clash on Mauchline Moor in June 1648 and at the Covenanters’ defeat by Cromwell at Dunbar on 3 September 1650. The memoir says only that when his side was routed he was “wonderfully preserved,” and that he was thankful for it all his life.
In 1651 the Church of Scotland split between the Resolutioners, who accepted resolutions letting former opponents of the Covenanting cause back into the army and public office, and the Protesters, who believed this betrayed the Covenant. Guthrie sided with the Protesters and moderated one of their synods. In 1654, under Cromwell, he was named one of the “triers” examining candidates for the ministry.
Silenced
When Charles II returned in 1660, bishops were restored to the Church of Scotland and the Covenants set aside. At the synod of Glasgow and Ayr in April 1661 Guthrie drafted an address to Parliament for the liberties of the church. That June his cousin James was hanged in Edinburgh for his testimony. The memoir says William walked with him to the place of execution, having earlier foretold that James would die by his enemies’ hands and he himself of the “gravel,” the kidney stones that troubled him for years.
For a time powerful friends shielded him. The Earl of Glencairn, now Chancellor, pleaded for him with the archbishops of Glasgow, but without success. “It cannot be,” Archbishop Burnet is reported to have said; “he is a ringleader and a keeper up of schism in my diocese.” On 24 July 1664 the archbishop’s commissioner declared the parish of Fenwick vacant, an act of doubtful legality.
The memoir, drawing on a paper found among his belongings, says he answered the curate firmly when he came. Charged with being unpeaceable, he replied that he was bidden to follow peace with all men, “but I know also I am bidden follow it with holiness.” Then he gave the curate and the soldiers refreshments and drank to them kindly, seeing them as men carrying out orders.
Dying in the Lord
He stayed for a time in the parish, but never preached there again. When the brother to whom he had given Pitforthy died, the estate came back to him, and he went home to Forfarshire. There his kidney disease grew rapidly worse. In his pain, the memoir records, he said, “Though I die mad, yet I know I shall die in the Lord.” It adds that men of every party visited him, the bishop of Brechin among them, and that he received them warmly despite all that divided them.
He died on 10 October 1665, in his forty-fifth year, at the house of his brother-in-law, the minister of Brechin, and was buried in Brechin Cathedral beneath the Pitforthy gallery. His widow Agnes survived him. In 1682 soldiers searched her house and carried off most of his papers. Their daughter Mary married Patrick Warner, minister of Irvine, and Mary’s daughter Margaret married Robert Wodrow, the historian of the Scottish church, through whose family many of the stories about Guthrie came down.
The book: The Christian’s Great Interest
In 1657 a volume appeared at Aberdeen under the florid title A Clear, Attractive, Warming Beam of Light: imperfect notes of Guthrie’s sermons on Isaiah 55, printed without his consent. In his preface he calls the title “vain” and “as displeasing to myself as the publishing of the thing.” To set the record right he wrote The Christian’s Great Interest, usually dated to 1658.
It has two parts. The first asks how a person can know whether he has a true and saving interest in Christ, and insists that this can be known, more surely and easily than many imagine. Guthrie examines the law’s work on conscience and the marks of true faith and of the new creature, set against their counterfeits. The second part speaks to the person who cannot find those marks, and urges him to close with Christ now, that is, to accept with the heart God’s way of saving sinners through Christ. It ends with counsel on making a personal covenant with God, with a model of what one might say, though Guthrie intends “no form of words for any person.”
What makes the book loved is its gentleness with the weak. Guthrie will not let anyone rest on a false confidence, but he refuses to make faith seem out of reach.
Shall that be judged a mysterious difficult thing; which doth consist much in desire? If men have but an appetite, they have it; for they are “blessed that hunger after righteousness.” If you will, you are welcome.
— William Guthrie, The Christian’s Great Interest, Of Faith
To the believer who fears his heart is too cold to covenant with God honestly, he answers that the heart is not yet wholly renewed in anyone:
It is well if there be a good part of the heart going out after Christ, desiring to close with him on his own terms.
— William Guthrie, The Christian’s Great Interest, Of Covenanting with God
A story told in the memoir and repeated by later writers says that John Owen, the great English Puritan theologian, took a little gilt copy from his pocket when a Scottish minister visited him, called its author “one of the greatest divines that ever wrote,” and said it held more divinity than all his own folios. It reaches us secondhand and cannot be checked against Owen’s own writings, but it shows how the book was prized.
What remains of Guthrie is the memory of a faithful parish minister and one small book, written in what he called “a most homely and plain style” for people with little money and little time. Readers who have wondered whether their faith is real will find in it a guide who takes their fear seriously, who will not flatter them, and who keeps pointing them away from themselves to Christ, who casts out none who come to him.
Questions and Answers
Who was William Guthrie?
William Guthrie (1620–1665) was a Scottish Presbyterian minister and Covenanter, the first minister of Fenwick parish in Ayrshire from 1644 until he was deprived in 1664. He is known chiefly for his book on assurance of salvation, The Christian’s Great Interest.
Where was William Guthrie born and educated?
He was born in 1620 at Pitforthy, near Brechin in Forfarshire (Angus), the eldest son of the laird. He studied at the University of St Andrews under his cousin James Guthrie, graduating Master of Arts on 5 June 1638, and then studied divinity under Samuel Rutherford.
Why did William Guthrie give away his estate?
According to the memoir printed with later editions of his book, Rutherford’s preaching brought him through a deep spiritual crisis to faith in Christ. He then made over the family estate of Pitforthy to one of his brothers so that he could give himself wholly to the ministry.
How did William Guthrie become minister of Fenwick?
While tutor to Lord Mauchline, son of the Earl of Loudoun, he preached at Galston, and people from the new parish of Fenwick who heard him urged their neighbours to call him. He was ordained there by the presbytery of Irvine on 7 November 1644.
Is it true that William Guthrie went fishing and fowling with his parishioners?
Yes, the old accounts say he was a keen angler and fowler whose health needed outdoor exercise, and his wit and unconventional dress earned him the name “the fool of Fenwick.” The memoir and John Howie’s Biographia Scoticana tell of him winning people for the church while out as a sportsman, including a Sunday fowler he paid half a crown to come to church, who later became an elder; these stories come from later tradition.
What part did William Guthrie play in the troubles of his time?
He served as an army chaplain and was present at Mauchline Moor in 1648 and the defeat at Dunbar in 1650. In the 1651 split in the Church of Scotland he sided with the Protesters, and after the Restoration he drafted the synod of Glasgow and Ayr’s 1661 address to Parliament for the church’s liberties.
Why was William Guthrie removed from Fenwick?
After bishops were restored to the Church of Scotland under Charles II, Guthrie refused to submit to episcopacy. Despite the Earl of Glencairn’s pleas, Archbishop Burnet called him a ringleader of schism, and on 24 July 1664 the parish was declared vacant.
What is The Christian’s Great Interest about?
The Christian’s Great Interest, usually dated 1658, grew out of sermons on Isaiah 55. Its first part shows how a person may know whether he has a true and saving interest in Christ, and its second part urges those who cannot find the marks of it to close with Christ, ending with counsel on personal covenanting with God. Guthrie wrote it after notes of his sermons were printed without his consent at Aberdeen in 1657.
Did John Owen really praise The Christian’s Great Interest?
A story told in the memoir and by later writers says John Owen showed a visiting Scottish minister a pocket copy and called its author one of the greatest divines that ever wrote. The account is secondhand, reported through that visitor, and is not found in Owen’s own writings, so it is best taken as an often-repeated tradition rather than a documented quotation.
When and how did William Guthrie die?
Long troubled by kidney stones, he returned to Pitforthy after his deprivation and grew gravely ill. He died on 10 October 1665, in his forty-fifth year, at his brother-in-law’s house in Brechin, and was buried in Brechin Cathedral.