The Missionary Century

Jesse Lyman Hurlbut

Jesse Lyman Hurlbut (1843–1930) was an American Methodist minister who spent over fifty years training Bible teachers through the Sunday school and the Chautauqua movement.

Born
1843
Died
1930
Tradition
Methodists
On Ochorus
1 book

Where to start reading

Start with

Hurlbut's Life of Christ for Young and Old

Begin reading
Reading plan Advent with the Classics 28 days

Books by Jesse Lyman Hurlbut (1)

Biography

Some servants of the church are remembered for a single hour — a sermon, a revival, a martyrdom. Jesse Lyman Hurlbut is remembered for something slower and humbler: more than half a century spent teaching people how to teach the Bible, and then, in his sixties and seventies, sitting down to tell its story himself in words a child could follow. He was a Methodist pastor, an editor, an organiser of classes and circles and leagues. But the thread that runs through every part of his long life is the conviction that the Scriptures belong to ordinary people, and that the best gift a teacher can give is to lead a learner straight to the Book itself.

A New York boyhood and a Methodist calling

Hurlbut was born in New York City in 1843. The record of his early years is thin. We know nothing certain of how his own faith began — no account of a conversion survives in the sources available to us — and it would be wrong to invent one. What is plain is where it led. He went to Wesleyan University in Middletown, Connecticut, the Methodist college of New England, and graduated in 1864, while the Civil War was still being fought.

That same year he taught languages at Pennington Seminary in New Jersey, a Methodist school, and soon afterwards he entered the Newark Conference of the Methodist Episcopal Church. His first station was Roseville, New Jersey, in 1865–66. There followed the ordinary itinerant life of a Methodist preacher: a few years in one pulpit, then the bishop’s appointment to the next. His pastorates read like a map of northern New Jersey — Newark, Montclair, Paterson, Plainfield, Hoboken, Morristown, Orange and Bloomfield. He married Mary Matilda Chase, and together they raised a family in the parsonages of those towns.

It is worth pausing on those years, because nothing about them is famous. A young minister preaching on Sundays, visiting the sick, burying the dead, and — as every Methodist pastor of his day was expected to do — watching over the Sunday school. It was there, in the least glamorous corner of the church’s life, that Hurlbut found the work that would become his own.

Beside the lake at Chautauqua

In August 1874 two Methodist men — John Heyl Vincent, a minister who had given himself to improving the Sunday school, and Lewis Miller, an Ohio manufacturer — gathered Sunday-school teachers at Fair Point on Chautauqua Lake in western New York. They called it the National Sunday School Assembly. The idea was simple and, for its time, bold: teachers of the Bible should themselves be taught, with a real course of study, real examinations, and a diploma earned rather than given.

Hurlbut came to the lake in 1875, the assembly’s second summer, and he never really left. He became one of Vincent’s closest helpers, supervising the Normal Courses — the teacher-training classes that were the heart of the early assemblies. They were not easy. By Hurlbut’s own account only about a tenth of those who attended the classes passed the examination and took the diploma. He wanted the Bible taught well, and he did not think that could be done cheaply.

Over the following decades he became one of Chautauqua’s best-loved teachers. He taught an adult Bible class each Sunday afternoon, spoke from the great platform, and lectured in Palestine Park, the scale model of the Holy Land laid out along the lake shore, where students could walk the length of the land in a few minutes and see its hills, lake and river laid out before them. The same impulse lies behind his Manual of Biblical Geography of 1882, later known as his Bible atlas: a teacher who wants his class to understand the story must first help them see the land where it happened.

When Vincent launched the Chautauqua Literary and Scientific Circle in 1878 — a four-year course of home reading that eventually reached vast numbers of ordinary men and women across America, many of whom had never had the chance of college — Hurlbut worked alongside him in its direction. He was one of the presidents of the Circle’s first graduating class, the Class of 1882, the “Pioneers.”

He loved the place and its stories. In his history of the movement he told how the famous Chautauqua Salute began in 1877: a deaf lecturer had finished speaking, and Vincent, realising the man could not hear the applause, asked the audience to wave their white handkerchiefs instead. The gesture caught on and became one of Chautauqua’s cherished customs — a small picture of what Hurlbut prized in the whole enterprise, a community that took thought for the one who could not otherwise share in it.

An editor for the Sunday schools

From 1879 Hurlbut’s work moved from the parish to the wider church. He was drawn into the Sunday-school and tract work of the Methodist Episcopal Church, and when Vincent was elected a bishop in 1888, Hurlbut took up the editing of the denomination’s Sunday-school literature and the work of its Sunday-School Union and Tract Society. For years he prepared commentaries and notes on the International Sunday-School Lessons — the Bible passages studied week by week in thousands of classrooms.

In May 1889 a group of Methodist leaders met at Cleveland to form the Epworth League, a society for the young people of the church, and Hurlbut served as its general secretary from 1889 to 1892, through its first years. Young people, Sunday-school teachers, adult learners at the lake: in every case his instinct was the same — organise, train, supply good books, and then trust the Word of God to do its work.

His manuals for the Sunday school are plain and practical. In Organizing and Building Up the Sunday School (1910) he insisted that a school’s success “depends not on a constitution, whether written or unwritten, but upon a man” — the superintendent — because an able leader will call forth or train up able workers. It is the conviction of a man who had spent his life raising up teachers.

The story-teller of the Bible

Out of all this came the books for which he is chiefly remembered. In 1904, at sixty-one, he published Hurlbut’s Story of the Bible, which retold the whole of Scripture, from Genesis to Revelation, in one hundred and sixty-eight stories, each complete in itself and together forming a connected narrative. He explained in his preface why he had done it:

Those who in childhood learn the Story of the Bible are fortunate, for they will never forget it.

— Jesse Lyman Hurlbut, preface to Hurlbut’s Story of the Bible (1904)

His aim, he wrote, was not merely to gather the most striking episodes but to tell all the principal stories in their order, so that a reader would find not only “stories from the Bible” but the “story of the Bible.” He deliberately kept close to the language of Scripture itself, so that the book would lead the young reader to the Bible and not away from it. Wise parents, he observed, already told these stories to their little children, and both parents and children found them the most fascinating of books. The volume went through edition after edition, and its distributors have counted more than four million copies in circulation since it first appeared.

In 1915 he did the same for the Gospels in Hurlbut’s Life of Christ for Young and Old. He held himself to a strict rule. So that the book would not lead its readers “away from the Bible, but directly toward it,” he introduced no imaginary scenes and no invented conversations.

The design has been to write the biography of Jesus, not a romance founded upon his life.

— Jesse Lyman Hurlbut, preface to Hurlbut’s Life of Christ (1915)

The opening chapter of that book shows the teacher at his best. Why should everybody know the life of Christ? Hurlbut gives his reasons one by one, the way he might have given them to a class: because Jesus is the most famous man who ever lived; because his story is full of wonders, and true; because he came to show us what God is like; because his life is the pattern for ours; because wherever he is known the world is made better; and, best of all, because through him our sins may be forgiven. He tells of an artist asked to paint a man who had died years before, who painted the father by studying the face of the son — and so, he says, if we know Christ, we know God. And to the child who hears a wonderful tale and looks up to ask, “Is it all true?”, he gives a direct answer:

Wonderful indeed are the stories told of Jesus; and the greatest wonder is that they are all true.

— Jesse Lyman Hurlbut, Hurlbut’s Life of Christ (1915)

Prayer runs quietly through those pages. He tells children that God is their Father, the Father of every one in all the world, to whom any child may go as he would go to his own father for whatever he needs.

He wrote for the church’s memory too. The Story of the Christian Church (1918) traced the church from Pentecost to his own day in a clear, compact narrative, with outlines in the margins for teachers and students. Like his Bible stories it has outlived him; in Spanish, as Historia de la Iglesia Cristiana, it is still in print and still studied.

The last years

Hurlbut never stopped being a pastor at heart. From 1909 until his retirement in 1914 he served as superintendent of the Newark District of his conference, overseeing the churches of the region where he had begun his ministry half a century before. In retirement he kept writing. In 1921 he published The Story of Chautauqua, a history of the movement told by one who had been there almost from the first summer, and dedicated to its two founders, Lewis Miller and John Heyl Vincent.

In 1924, when Chautauqua kept its fiftieth anniversary, Hurlbut — by then past eighty and one of the very few still living who had known its beginnings — gave an address on “Memories of Early Days.” He was speaking of summers he had seen with his own eyes, when the idea of teaching the teachers of the Bible was still new.

He died in New Jersey in 1930, at the age of eighty-seven. The following year a church was opened on the Chautauqua grounds and named in his memory: the Hurlbut Memorial Church, where a Methodist congregation still worships beside the lake where he taught for more than fifty summers.

A legacy of plain words

Hurlbut was not an original theologian, nor a great preacher whose sermons are still read, nor a missionary who crossed oceans. His gift was of another kind, and the church needs it just as much. He believed that the Bible could be understood by anyone who was patiently and faithfully taught, and he spent his life making that true — training teachers by the thousand, editing the lessons they taught, and at last telling the old story himself, so simply that a child could follow it and so faithfully that the child would want to go on to the Bible.

Generations of children first met Abraham and Joseph, Ruth and David, and above all Jesus, in his pages. Whenever one of them went on from his pages to the Scriptures themselves, it was exactly what he had hoped for. There are worse epitaphs for a Christian teacher than that his books led people past themselves to the Book he loved.

Questions and Answers

Who was Jesse Lyman Hurlbut?

Jesse Lyman Hurlbut (1843–1930) was an American minister of the Methodist Episcopal Church who spent more than half a century teaching people how to teach the Bible. He served pastorates across northern New Jersey, helped John Heyl Vincent build the Chautauqua movement, edited Methodist Sunday-school literature, and in later life wrote Hurlbut’s Story of the Bible (1904) and Hurlbut’s Life of Christ (1915), which retold Scripture plainly for children and adults alike.

Where was Hurlbut born, and where was he educated?

He was born in New York City in 1843 and graduated from Wesleyan University, the Methodist college in Middletown, Connecticut, in 1864, while the Civil War was still being fought. That same year he taught languages at Pennington Seminary, a Methodist school in New Jersey, before entering the Newark Conference of the Methodist Episcopal Church. Little else is recorded of his early years, and no account of his conversion survives in the available sources.

Where did Hurlbut serve as a pastor?

After entering the Newark Conference he was first stationed at Roseville, New Jersey, in 1865–66. His later pastorates read like a map of northern New Jersey: Newark, Montclair, Paterson, Plainfield, Hoboken, Morristown, Orange and Bloomfield. Near the end of his active ministry, from 1909 until his retirement in 1914, he served as superintendent of the Newark District, overseeing the churches of the region where he had begun half a century before.

What was Hurlbut’s part in the Chautauqua movement?

Chautauqua began in August 1874 as a National Sunday School Assembly on Chautauqua Lake, New York, founded by John Heyl Vincent and Lewis Miller to train Bible teachers. Hurlbut arrived in 1875, its second summer, and became one of Vincent’s closest helpers, supervising the demanding Normal Courses for teachers, teaching a Sunday-afternoon adult Bible class, lecturing in Palestine Park, and helping direct the Chautauqua Literary and Scientific Circle founded in 1878.

What did Hurlbut do for the Sunday school and the Epworth League?

From 1879 he worked in the Sunday-school and tract work of the Methodist Episcopal Church, and after Vincent became a bishop in 1888 he took up the editing of the denomination’s Sunday-school literature, preparing notes on the International Sunday-School Lessons. When the Epworth League, a society for the church’s young people, was formed at Cleveland in 1889, he served as its general secretary until 1892.

What is Hurlbut’s Story of the Bible?

Published in 1904, it retells the whole of Scripture from Genesis to Revelation in one hundred and sixty-eight stories, each complete in itself yet together forming a connected narrative. Hurlbut kept close to the language of the Bible so that the book would lead young readers to Scripture rather than away from it. In his preface he wrote, "Those who in childhood learn the Story of the Bible are fortunate, for they will never forget it." More than four million copies have been counted in circulation.

How is Hurlbut’s Life of Christ different from other children’s lives of Jesus?

Hurlbut held himself to a strict rule: no imaginary scenes and no invented conversations, so that the book would lead readers directly toward the Bible. In his 1915 preface he wrote, "The design has been to write the biography of Jesus, not a romance founded upon his life." Its opening chapter gives, like a teacher to a class, his reasons why everyone should know the story of Jesus, ending with the forgiveness of sins.

What did Hurlbut teach children about prayer?

In his Life of Christ he told young readers that God is the Father of every one in all the world, to whom any child may go for whatever he needs. He wrote that if Jesus had done no more for us than to teach us the Lord’s Prayer, beginning "Our Father who art in heaven," he would have done enough to make us love him. He sent the book out with his own prayer: "May it help many, young and old, to know Jesus better, to love him more, and to follow him more closely!"

What other books did Jesse Lyman Hurlbut write?

Besides his Bible stories he wrote a Manual of Biblical Geography (1882), later known as his Bible atlas; practical Sunday-school manuals such as Organizing and Building Up the Sunday School (1910); The Story of the Christian Church (1918), still studied today in Spanish as Historia de la Iglesia Cristiana; and The Story of Chautauqua (1921), a history of the movement dedicated to its founders, Lewis Miller and John Heyl Vincent.

When did Hurlbut die, and how is he remembered?

He died in New Jersey in 1930, at the age of eighty-seven. In 1924, past eighty, he had given an address on "Memories of Early Days" at Chautauqua’s fiftieth anniversary. The year after his death the Hurlbut Memorial Church was opened on the Chautauqua grounds in his memory. He is remembered as a teacher of teachers whose plain, faithful retellings led generations of children to the Bible itself.