The Early Church

Irenaeus of Lyons

Irenaeus of Lyons (c. 130–c.

Born
130
Died
202
Tradition
Early church
Place
France
On Ochorus
1 book

Where to start reading

Start with

Against Heresies

Begin reading

Books by Irenaeus of Lyons (1)

Biography

Irenaeus lived a long way from the places where the church’s story usually gets told. He grew up in the Greek East, among people who remembered the apostles, and spent his working life on the far western edge of the Christian world, in a river town in Gaul where he says he mostly used “a barbarous dialect.” His Greek name comes from the word for peace. Yet he is remembered chiefly for a fight: the long, patient, five-book argument against the Gnostic teachers that we call Against Heresies. He wrote it not as a man who enjoyed controversy but as a pastor who saw his people being drawn away, and who wanted to keep both the faith and the flock.

A boy who listened to Polycarp

We know very little about his early life. He is generally thought to have come from Smyrna, the busy port on the Aegean coast of Asia Minor (today İzmir in Turkey), though one nineteenth-century editor thought he may have been born in Syria and brought to Smyrna as a boy. His birth year is uncertain. The editors of the Ante-Nicene Fathers place it “somewhere between a.d. 120 and a.d. 140,” and their heading gives 120; many accounts settle around 130. Unlike many Christians of his age, he seems to have been raised in the faith rather than converted as an adult.

The one fixed point of his youth is a person. Smyrna’s bishop was Polycarp, an old man said to have heard John, the disciple of the Lord. Irenaeus tells us himself that Polycarp was one “whom I also saw in my early youth, for he tarried [on earth] a very long time,” and who died “having always taught the things which he had learned from the apostles.” Polycarp was martyred around 155. It was a living chain: the apostles taught Polycarp, Polycarp taught his church, and a boy in the congregation carried that teaching for the rest of his life. When teachers later claimed a secret tradition from Jesus, Irenaeus could answer that he had sat under a man who knew the apostles and heard no such thing.

To the banks of the Rhone

How he came to Gaul is not recorded, but there was a brisk trade between Smyrna and Marseilles, and the gospel had travelled with it. At Lyons — then the Roman city of Lugdunum — the church was led by a venerable bishop named Pothinus. Old tradition, followed by the ANF editor, says that Polycarp had sent Pothinus into Gaul as an evangelist, and that Irenaeus joined him there as a presbyter, an elder of the church. In 177, under the emperor Marcus Aurelius, that small congregation was struck by one of the most terrible persecutions of the century, and “the martyrs of Lyons and Vienne,” its neighbouring town, became famous throughout the church. Pothinus was among those who died.

While the persecution was under way, members of the church awaiting martyrdom sent Irenaeus to Rome, with a letter to Eleutherus, the bishop there. The historian Eusebius records the errand; the letter is said to have concerned the Montanists, a movement of new prophecy. He may also have written the surviving account of the martyrs’ sufferings, though that is uncertain. When he came home he found Pothinus dead, and he was chosen to succeed him, probably about 177 — the second bishop of Lyons — in a church that had just buried its leaders.

The teachers of a secret knowledge

The danger he saw was not persecution but persuasion. Through the second century a number of teachers offered what they called gnosis, “knowledge” — a hidden wisdom for the spiritually advanced. Irenaeus studied most closely the system of Valentinus and his followers. In their account the true God dwelt far off in a fullness (the pleroma) of divine beings called Æons. One of the youngest, Sophia, or Wisdom, longed to grasp the unknowable Father and fell into passion and grief, and from that fall the material world eventually came to be, shaped by a lesser maker, the Demiurge. Human beings fell into classes — material, psychic and spiritual — and only the spiritual would be fully redeemed, freed from body and soul alike.

It is right to be fair to them. The ANF translators, no friends of Gnosticism, grant that it was trying “to solve the two grand problems of all religious philosophy”: how to account for evil, and how to reconcile the finite with the infinite. Some modern historians, notably Elaine Pagels, have charged that Irenaeus painted Gnostics as libertines when some were stricter ascetics than the orthodox. Since the Nag Hammadi library was found in 1945, the broad scholarly judgement has been that Irenaeus reported their beliefs fairly accurately, though the groups were more varied than any one summary allows.

What troubled Irenaeus was close at hand. Followers of a teacher named Marcus were at work, he says, “in our own district of the Rhone,” and he had read the Valentinians’ writings and talked with some of them himself. So he set himself, as the ANF editor puts it, to study these systems “like a wise physician,” so that others could recognise them. He began with an apology for his plain style:

Thou wilt not expect from me, who am resident among the Keltæ, and am accustomed for the most part to use a barbarous dialect, any display of rhetoric, which I have never learned, or any excellence of composition, which I have never practised, or any beauty and persuasiveness of style, to which I make no pretensions.

— Irenaeus, Against Heresies, Book I, Preface

One God, one Christ, one story

Against the picture of a distant God, a botched creation and an elite saved out of the body, Irenaeus set a single, sweeping story. There is one good God, who made the world himself and has never stopped caring for it. He made humanity young and unfinished, meaning it to grow slowly into his likeness. When Adam fell, God did not abandon the plan; he sent his Son to take it up from within. Irenaeus called this recapitulation, a “summing up”: Christ, the new Adam, passes through every stage of human life and undoes the old disobedience by his obedience — the tree of the cross answering the tree in the garden. He was the first writer we know of to set Mary’s faithfulness against Eve’s faithlessness. And because the Word truly became flesh, the flesh itself will be saved; the fifth book is given to the resurrection of the body. Salvation is not escape from creation but its healing.

For the glory of God is a living man; and the life of man consists in beholding God.

— Irenaeus, Against Heresies, Book IV

But how could anyone tell whose reading of Scripture was true, when both sides quoted it? Irenaeus pointed to what the churches held in common: the Scriptures; the rule of faith, a short summary of belief much like the later Apostles’ Creed; and the teaching handed down by the bishops of the apostles’ churches, whose names could be listed back to the beginning. He gave Rome as his chief example, saying every church should agree with it “on account of its pre-eminent authority” — a passage Catholics and Protestants have argued over for centuries. And he is the earliest surviving writer to insist on four Gospels, no more and no fewer, “four pillars, breathing out immortality on every side.”

He had his oddities, which his translators name plainly: he held that Christ lived to be an older man, with a ministry of many years, and he looked for a literal earthly reign of Christ before the end.

The peacemaker

Little is known of his years as bishop; the reports of his missionary labours in southern Gaul are late and uncertain. The last thing told of him, by Eusebius, best suits his name. The churches of Asia Minor, his homeland, kept Easter on the fourteenth day of the Jewish month of Nisan, the day of the Passover, whatever day of the week it fell on; they were called Quartodecimans, the fourteenth-day keepers. Rome kept it on a Sunday. Polycarp and the Roman bishop Anicetus had once agreed to differ in peace. But around 190 Victor, bishop of Rome, moved to cut the Asian churches off from communion.

Irenaeus wrote to him — only a fragment of the letter survives — warning, as the ANF editors summarise it, that if he persisted the effect would be “to rend the Catholic Church in pieces.” The letter “had the desired result,” and the question was debated more temperately until the Council of Nicaea settled it. When Pope Francis named Irenaeus a Doctor of the Church in 2022, he gave him the added title Doctor unitatis, “Doctor of Unity.” The man who wrote five books against division also kept his own church from causing one.

An uncertain end

We do not know when or how Irenaeus died. It was at the end of the second century or the beginning of the third; the traditional date is about 202. The story that he was martyred goes back to Jerome, writing long afterwards, and the ANF translators note that neither Tertullian nor Eusebius, nor other early authorities, mentions it. The Catholic Church and some in the Orthodox Church honour him as a martyr; the honest answer is that the early record is silent. He was buried in Lyons under the Church of St John, later renamed for him.

His influence was immediate: Hippolytus and Tertullian drew freely on him. He is honoured as a saint across the Catholic, Orthodox, Anglican and Lutheran traditions, on 28 June in the West and 23 August in the Orthodox East. One other short work, the Demonstration of the Apostolic Preaching, was found in an Armenian copy in 1904; the rest of his books are lost.

Reading him now

Against Heresies — in full, A Refutation and Subversion of Knowledge falsely so called — was written around 180. Its Greek is lost except for much of the first book, quoted by later writers; it survives whole in an ancient Latin version. Our text is Alexander Roberts and W. H. Rambaut’s translation from the Ante-Nicene Fathers of 1885, and the translators warn honestly that Irenaeus is often obscure, and that the reader’s patience is “sorely tried” by the first two books, which describe and refute the Gnostic systems in detail. A reader may fairly begin with Books III to V, where Irenaeus sets out the faith itself.

It repays the effort. Few books bring us closer to a church still within living memory of the apostles, already sure that the truth was not a secret for the few but a gift for all. Irenaeus ends the preface to his fifth book with the line that is the heart of his legacy, and the reason the boy who listened to Polycarp spent his life on the banks of the Rhone:

the Word of God, our Lord Jesus Christ, who did, through His transcendent love, become what we are, that He might bring us to be even what He is Himself.

— Irenaeus, Against Heresies, Book V, Preface

Questions and Answers

Who was Irenaeus of Lyons?

Irenaeus was a second-century Greek Christian from Asia Minor who became the second bishop of Lyons in Roman Gaul. He is best known for Against Heresies, his five-book refutation of the Gnostic teachers, and is honoured as a saint across the Catholic, Orthodox, Anglican and Lutheran traditions.

When and where was Irenaeus born?

His birth year is uncertain: the Ante-Nicene Fathers editors place it somewhere between 120 and 140, and many accounts settle around 130. He is generally thought to have come from Smyrna in Asia Minor, though one nineteenth-century editor suggested he was born in Syria and moved to Smyrna as a boy.

What was his connection to Polycarp?

As a young man in Smyrna, Irenaeus saw and heard Polycarp, the city's aged bishop, who was said to have been taught by John the disciple of the Lord. Irenaeus treated that memory as a living link to the apostles' own teaching, and appealed to it against those who claimed a secret tradition.

How did Irenaeus come to Lyons?

The details are not recorded, but there was a brisk trade between Smyrna and Marseilles, and the gospel came to southern Gaul from Asia Minor. Tradition says Polycarp sent the evangelist Pothinus to Gaul, and Irenaeus served under Pothinus at Lyons as a presbyter, or elder.

What happened during the persecution at Lyons in 177?

Under the emperor Marcus Aurelius the churches of Lyons and Vienne suffered a terrible persecution, and the martyrs of Lyons and Vienne became famous throughout the church; the aged bishop Pothinus was among those who died. During the persecution Irenaeus was sent to Rome with a letter to Bishop Eleutherus, and on his return he succeeded Pothinus as bishop, probably about 177.

Who were the Gnostics Irenaeus opposed?

They were second-century teachers, notably the followers of Valentinus, who offered a hidden knowledge, or gnosis, for the spiritually advanced. Many taught that the material world came from a fall among divine beings and was shaped by a lesser maker, and that the spiritual few would be freed from the body; modern scholars broadly judge that Irenaeus reported their beliefs fairly accurately, though the groups varied widely.

What did Irenaeus teach against them?

He taught one good God who made the world and guides all of history, and a humanity created young and meant to grow into God's likeness. Christ, the new Adam, sums up and heals human life, undoing Adam's disobedience by his obedience, and the body itself will be raised. He appealed to the Scriptures, including four Gospels, to the rule of faith, and to the teaching handed down by the bishops of the apostolic churches.

How did Irenaeus help settle the Easter controversy?

Around 190, Victor, bishop of Rome, moved to cut off the churches of Asia Minor, which kept Easter on the fourteenth day of the Jewish month of Nisan rather than on a Sunday. Irenaeus wrote warning him that this would rend the church in pieces, and the letter had the desired result; Pope Francis later named him the Doctor of Unity.

How did Irenaeus die?

Nothing certain is known about his death, which came at the end of the second century or the beginning of the third; the traditional date is about 202. The tradition that he was martyred goes back to Jerome, writing long afterwards, and is not mentioned by Tertullian, Eusebius or other early authorities.

What is Against Heresies, and is it worth reading today?

Against Heresies, written around 180, is a five-book description and refutation of the Gnostic systems and a defence of the apostolic faith; it survives whole in an ancient Latin version, here in the 1885 Ante-Nicene Fathers translation by Alexander Roberts and W. H. Rambaut. The first two books are heavy going, but Books III to V set out the faith itself and contain lines such as 'the glory of God is a living man.'