Chapter 17 · 9 min read · 11 min listen
“Our Heart Is Restless”
“I am quiet before God alone; my rescue comes from Him.” (Psalm 62:1)
The house in Milan had a small garden. The owner was away, so the two friends who were staying there could use it as they liked. On a summer day in the year 386, one of them rushed out into it as if he were running from a fire.
His name was Augustine. He was thirty-one years old, a teacher of public speaking with a good post in one of the most important cities of the Roman Empire. He had friends and a bright future. And he was in agony.
Through the preaching of Ambrose, the bishop of Milan, he had come to see that the Christian faith was true. But he could not let go of his old life, especially his desires for sexual pleasure. A visitor had just told him and his friend Alypius about Antony, the Egyptian monk who gave up everything to follow Christ, and about two officials who had read Antony’s story and given their lives to God at once. Augustine was ashamed. Simple people were taking hold of heaven, and he, with all his learning, still could not move.
Some ten years later he told what happened next in his Confessions.
He threw himself down under a fig tree and wept. He cried out to God in the words of the Psalms, and then in his own: “How long, how long, ‘to-morrow, and tomorrow?’ Why not now?”
Then he heard a voice from a house nearby, a child’s voice, singing again and again, “Take up and read; Take up and read.” He knew no children’s game with words like that. He remembered that Antony, as we saw in chapter 9, had heard a reading from the Gospel and taken it as God’s word to him. So Augustine got up, went back to the bench where he had left a book of Paul’s letters, opened it, and read the first words his eyes fell on. They were these:
“Let us live decently, as people do in the daytime: not in wild parties and drunkenness, not in sexual immorality and shameless excess, not in quarrels and envy. Instead, put on the Lord Jesus Christ like clothing, and do not make plans to satisfy the desires of the flesh.” (Romans 13:13-14)
He read no further. He did not need to. “By a light as it were of serenity infused into my heart,” he wrote, “all the darkness of doubt vanished away.” He went in with Alypius to tell his mother, whose long years of prayer we followed in the last chapter.
Who he was
As we saw in the last chapter, Augustine was not a good young man. He was proud, ambitious and restless. The woman he lived with for many years had borne him a son, Adeodatus. And as a follower of the Manichees, who taught that the world was a battle between light and darkness, he had looked down on the Bible as crude.
He was also honest, and that honesty finally brought him home. At Easter in 387 he was baptized by Ambrose in Milan, together with Alypius and his son. Back in Africa, he hoped for a quiet life of prayer and study, but in 391 the church in the port town of Hippo seized him and asked their bishop to make him a priest. A few years later he became bishop of Hippo himself, and he served there for the rest of his life. He preached, cared for the poor and wrote books that have shaped Christian thinking ever since.
He never forgot what he had been. His most famous book is not a book of theology at all. It is a confession, spoken to God, of his sins and of God’s mercy. And it begins with a sentence that Christians all over the world know by heart:
“Thou awakest us to delight in Thy praise; for Thou madest us for Thyself, and our heart is restless, until it repose in Thee.”
Augustine of Hippo, Confessions
Prayer as holy desire
That sentence is the key to Augustine’s teaching on prayer. Every human heart is hungry. We look for rest in money, pleasure or praise, and none of it is enough, because we were made for God. Prayer, for Augustine, is that hunger turned toward the One who can fill it.
So he talked much about desire. Our desires are not the enemy; the problem is that they are divided. Augustine admitted that as a young man he had prayed, “Give me chastity and continency, only not yet.” He wanted God, but he wanted other things more. Real prayer begins when our deepest desire becomes God Himself.
Once he preached on the words “we will be like Him, for we will see Him as He truly is” (1 John 3:2). We cannot see God fully now, he said. So what are we to do in the meantime? Desire Him:
“The whole life of a good Christian is an holy desire. Now what thou longest for, thou dost not yet see: howbeit by longing, thou art made capable, so that when that is come which thou mayest see, thou shall be filled.”
Augustine of Hippo, Homilies on the First Epistle of John
He compared it to stretching open a sack so that it can hold more. “So God, by deferring our hope, stretches our desire; by the desiring, stretches the mind; by stretching, makes it more capacious.” When God makes us wait, He is not ignoring us. He is making room in us for what He wants to give.
Years later, a wealthy Roman widow named Proba wrote to ask him how she ought to pray. She had fled to Africa after the city of Rome was sacked by the Goths in 410. His long letter to her is not yet in the Ochorus library, but here are its main lines. Pray for a happy life, he told her, and know that true happiness is found only in God. God does not need us to tell Him what we need. He asks us to pray so that our desire may grow, and we may become able to receive what He is ready to give. The Lord’s Prayer, he wrote, holds everything we may rightly ask. And to “never stop praying” (1 Thessalonians 5:17) is to keep this longing for God alive in faith, hope and love all through the day, even when our lips are silent.
There is one more lesson. Augustine knew that God sometimes refuses what we ask, as He refused his mother’s prayer that he would not sail. So he wrote:
“He is Thy best servant who looks not so much to hear that from Thee which himself willeth, as rather to will that, which from Thee he heareth.”
Augustine of Hippo, Confessions
That is where the restless heart finds rest. “I am quiet before God alone; my rescue comes from Him” (Psalm 62:1). Augustine died in 430, while an army of Vandals was besieging Hippo. His friend Possidius, who wrote his life, tells us that in his last illness he had the psalms of repentance copied out and fixed to the wall where he could see them from his bed, and he read them and wept. The great teacher ended his life as he had begun his new one: asking for mercy, and resting in God.
Three key insights
- We were made for God, and our hearts find rest only in Him. Every restless longing in us is, underneath, a longing for God. Prayer is where we bring that hunger to the only One who can satisfy it.
- God stretches our hearts by making us wait. Unanswered prayer is not wasted time. While we keep desiring and asking, God is enlarging our hearts to receive more of Him.
- The best prayer learns to want what God wants. We begin by asking God for our wishes. We grow by asking Him to make His will our wish.
For us today
Augustine’s restlessness is not only a problem of the rich West. A young man in Nairobi scrolling his phone at midnight, a businesswoman in Shanghai who has everything except peace, a farmer in Bangladesh who feels his life is going nowhere: all of them know the ache he described. Augustine tried money, pleasure and success to quiet it. None of them worked.
The good news is that the ache itself can become a prayer. Bring your desires to God, the good and the confused alike, and ask Him to sort them out. Ask Him to make Himself your deepest desire.
If you are praying “but not yet,” be honest with God about that too. He heard that half-hearted prayer and kept working until the day in the garden. He can do the same for you.
Try this
This week, let Augustine teach you to pray your desires.
- Pray his first sentence. Each morning, say slowly in your own words: You made me for Yourself, and my heart is restless until it rests in You. Then sit quietly before God for a minute, as Psalm 62:1 says.
- Name your restlessness. Write down three things you have been looking to for happiness. Hand each one to God in prayer and ask Him to be your true joy.
- Pray the Lord’s Prayer slowly. Augustine told Proba that it holds everything we may rightly ask. Pray it one line at a time, and let each line shape your own requests.
A closing prayer
Lord God, You made me for Yourself, and my heart is restless until it rests in You. You know how divided my desires are. You know the things I still say “not yet” to. Have mercy on me. Stretch my heart while I wait. Teach me to want You more than Your gifts, and to want Your will more than my own. Let me be quiet before You alone, for my rescue comes from You. Clothe me with the Lord Jesus Christ, and give me rest in Him. Amen.
Questions for reflection
- Where do you most often look for rest instead of looking to God?
- Augustine prayed, “only not yet.” Is there anything you are saying “not yet” to God about?
- How might it change your prayers to think of waiting as God stretching your heart?
Read more on Ochorus
- Augustine of Hippo, Confessions, especially “Book VIII”
- Augustine of Hippo, Homilies on the First Epistle of John, especially the fourth homily, on God’s love and our longing for Him
- Ochorus Originals, The Key Teachings of Augustine of Hippo, especially “Restless Until It Rests in Thee”