Faithful unto Death
The Child of Those Tears

Chapter 16 · 9 min read · 11 min listen

The Child of Those Tears

“Get up and cry aloud in the night, as each watch of the night begins; empty out your heart like water before the Lord’s face. Raise your hands to Him for the lives of your little ones...” (Lamentations 2:19)

It was night at the harbor of Carthage, the great city on the coast of North Africa, in the year 383. A ship was waiting for the wind to sail for Rome. A young teacher named Augustine, about twenty-nine years old, meant to be on it. His mother, Monica, had followed him down to the sea. She held on to him, begging him to stay or to take her with him.

He did neither. He told her a lie. He said that a friend of his was sailing and that he only wanted to keep the friend company until the wind was right. He persuaded her to spend the night in a small chapel near the ship, built in memory of Cyprian, the martyred bishop of Carthage, whom we met in chapter 8.

So Monica went into the chapel to pray, and Augustine slipped away in the dark. Years later Augustine wrote it down in his Confessions, a long prayer to God telling the story of his life:

“That night I privily departed, but she was not behind in weeping and prayer.”

Augustine of Hippo, Confessions

What was she asking for, with so many tears? That God would not let him sail. The wind rose, the sails filled, and the shore disappeared behind him. In the morning Monica stood at the water’s edge, overcome with grief, and found the ship gone. She had prayed all night for one thing, and God had not given it.

And yet Augustine says she did not stop. After she had grieved, and complained of his cruelty, she “betook herself again to intercede to Thee for me.” She went home and kept praying.

Who she was

Monica was born around the year 331 in Thagaste, a small town in the Roman province of Numidia, in what is now Algeria. She grew up in a Christian home. Augustine tells us that an old servant woman of the family trained her in self-control and the fear of God.

She was married young to Patricius, a town councillor who was not a Christian and who had a hot temper. Other women in the town were often beaten by their husbands, and they wondered why Monica never was. She told them her secret: she never answered her husband while he was angry, but waited until he was calm. She bore his unfaithfulness patiently and prayed for him. Toward the end of his life, Augustine says, she won him to Christ.

Augustine was born in 354. He was brilliant and restless. As a student in Carthage he lived with a woman outside marriage and had a son by her. He joined a sect called the Manichees, whose teaching was far from the Christian faith. Monica grieved over him as if he had died. Augustine says she wept for him “more than mothers weep the bodily deaths of their children,” and that her tears “watered the ground under her eyes in every place where she prayed.”

At one point she begged a bishop in Africa to talk with her son and argue him out of his errors. The bishop wisely refused. Augustine was too proud to listen yet, he said; “only pray God for him.” When she would not stop pleading with him, and her tears kept falling, he sent her away with words she never forgot:

“Go thy ways and God bless thee, for it is not possible that the son of these tears should perish.”

Augustine of Hippo, Confessions

Augustine says she took this answer “as if it had sounded from heaven.” It would be years more before her son came home to God.

How she prayed

Monica’s prayers were not elegant. They were tears. Augustine pictures her coming to church “twice a day, morning and evening,” not for gossip, “but that she might hear Thee in Thy discourses, and Thou her in her prayers.” She asked God, he says, not for gold or silver, but for the salvation of her son’s soul.

The strangest part of her story is that night in Carthage. Her prayer was refused. But Augustine, looking back as a bishop, saw that the refusal was the answer. If he had stayed in Africa, he would never have gone to Milan, never have heard the great bishop Ambrose preach, and never have found Christ there. He wrote this to God:

“But Thou, in the depth of Thy counsels and hearing the main point of her desire, regardest not what she then asked, that Thou mightest make me what she ever asked.”

Augustine of Hippo, Confessions

Arthur T. Pierson, telling the story of George Müller, put it in one plain sentence:

“God fulfilled the mother’s desire while denying her request.”

Arthur T. Pierson, George Müller of Bristol

Monica followed him across the sea to Milan. Bishop Ambrose came to love her, and would congratulate Augustine on having such a mother. And in the summer of 386, in a garden in Milan, the son of those tears gave his life to Christ. We will stand in that garden in the next chapter. Here we only need to see Monica’s face when Augustine and his friend Alypius came in to tell her. “She leaps for joy,” he wrote, “and triumpheth, and blesseth Thee.” God had given her more than she had asked.

The next year they set out for home together. At Ostia, the port of Rome, while they waited for a ship, Monica and Augustine stood alone at a window looking into a garden, talking about the life of the saints with God. In that conversation, Augustine says, they seemed for a moment to reach up toward God Himself. Then Monica said:

“One thing there was for which I desired to linger for a while in this life, that I might see thee a Catholic Christian before I died. My God hath done this for me more abundantly, that I should now see thee withal, despising earthly happiness, become His servant: what do I here?”

Augustine of Hippo, Confessions

A few days later she fell ill with a fever. She asked her sons not to worry about where her body was buried: “this only I request, that you would remember me at the Lord’s altar, wherever you be.” (Christians of different traditions understand prayer for those who have died in different ways. All of us can see in her words a heart that wanted to stay close to her family in Christ.) When someone asked if she was afraid to die so far from home, she answered, “Nothing is far to God.” She died in the fifty-sixth year of her age, in 387. Augustine was thirty-three.

Three key insights

  1. Tears poured out before God are a kind of prayer. Monica did not have fine words. She emptied out her heart like water before the Lord, as Lamentations says. God saw every tear.
  2. God may refuse our request in order to grant our deepest desire. Monica asked that her son would not sail. God let him sail, so that he would become what she always asked. A “no” from God may be part of a greater “yes.”
  3. Prayer for a wandering child is never wasted. Monica prayed for many years, and for a long time nothing seemed to change. But God was at work the whole time, and her prayers were answered beyond what she imagined.

For us today

Some of you are praying for a son or daughter who has walked away from God, or for a husband who is harsh, as Patricius was. Some have children who have gone far away to find work, and you do not know how they are living. Monica’s story is for you.

R. A. Torrey, the American Bible teacher, saw in her story a lesson every praying parent needs:

“How utterly all of Monica’s efforts and entreaties failed with her son, but her prayers prevailed with God, and the dissolute youth became St. Augustine, the mighty man of God.”

R. A. Torrey, How to Pray

Notice what the wise bishop told her: talk less, pray more. There is a time to speak to our children about God. There are also long seasons when our words only push them away, and the best thing we can do is keep loving them and keep praying.

And do not be afraid of God’s “no.” When a door closes or a plan falls apart, God has not stopped listening. He may be carrying your prayer somewhere you could not have planned.

Try this

This week, pray like Monica for someone you love who is far from God.

  • Name them before God, morning and evening. Like Monica, come to God twice a day, even for one minute, and say their name to Him.
  • Pour out your heart. Read Lamentations 2:19 aloud. Then tell God everything you feel about this person, even if it comes out as tears instead of words.
  • Speak less, love more. Ask God to show you whether your words are helping or hurting. Choose one act of quiet love for this person this week.
  • Ask for the deepest thing. Pray, “Lord, do not give me only what I ask. Give them what I truly desire: that they would know You.”

A closing prayer

Father, You saw every tear Monica wept for her son, and You did not despise them. I bring You the people I love who are far from You. I name them before You now. I do not know how to reach them, but You do. When You do not give me what I ask, help me trust that You are working toward what I most desire. Keep me praying through the long years. Let my tears be prayers, and let them not be wasted. Bring my loved ones home to You, as You brought Augustine home. Amen.

Questions for reflection

  • Who are you praying for, as Monica prayed for Augustine? How long have you been praying?
  • Can you remember a time when God’s “no” turned out to be a deeper “yes”?
  • Why do you think the bishop told Monica to talk less and pray more? When might that be wise for you?

Read more on Ochorus

  • Augustine of Hippo, Confessions, especially “Book IX”
  • Ochorus Originals, The Key Teachings of Augustine of Hippo, especially “The Son of These Tears”
  • R. A. Torrey, How to Pray, especially “The Importance of Prayer”
Previous Next