A Mighty Fortress
Search Me, O God

Chapter 9 · 9 min read · 11 min listen

Search Me, O God

“God, look deep into me and know my heart; put me to the test and know my restless thoughts. Look and see whether I am on a path that brings harm, and guide me along the road that never ends.” (Psalm 139:23-24)

In May 1521, a French army surrounded the fortress of Pamplona, in the north of Spain. The Spanish soldiers inside knew they could not win, and most of them wanted to surrender. But one proud young officer, a Basque nobleman named Íñigo of Loyola, persuaded the commander to fight on. When the walls were broken, he stood fighting until a cannon ball struck him. It broke one of his legs and badly hurt the other.

The French treated him kindly and sent him home to his family’s castle at Loyola. His leg had been set badly, so the doctors broke it again and reset it. He grew so ill that they expected him to die, but he recovered. Then, because a piece of bone stuck out below his knee and spoiled the look of his leg, he asked them to cut it away, though they warned him it would hurt more than everything before. He wanted to look fine at court.

For weeks he had to lie in bed. He loved stories of knights and adventure, and he asked for some to pass the time. But there were none in the house. Instead they gave him a Life of Christ and a book of the lives of the saints. He began to read, and his mind went two ways. For hours he daydreamed of the great deeds he would do to win the favor of a noble lady. Then he would read of the saints and think, “What if I should do what St. Francis did?”

Slowly he noticed something. “When he thought of worldly things it gave him great pleasure, but afterward he found himself dry and sad.” But when he thought of following Christ, the joy stayed with him even after he stopped thinking. One day, the account says, “the eyes of his soul were opened.” He “learned by experience that one train of thought left him sad, the other joyful.” This, it adds, was “his first reasoning on spiritual matters.”

We know this story because near the end of his life, Ignatius, as he was later called, told it to a younger friend, who wrote it down. It is told about him in the third person. We quote the English translation of J. F. X. O’Conor, published in 1900.

Who he was

Íñigo was born in 1491 in the Basque country of northern Spain, the youngest son of a noble family. As a young man he served at court and as a soldier, and by his own account he cared mostly for fame. After his recovery he gave up that life. At the shrine of Montserrat he hung up his sword and dagger in the church, and then spent about a year in the town of Manresa, praying for many hours a day and begging for his food.

Manresa was not easy for him. He was tormented by guilt over his past sins, and for a time he could find no peace, even after confessing them again and again. But God brought him through, and he began to write down what he learned about prayer and about the movements of the heart. These notes became a small book, The Spiritual Exercises.

He went on a pilgrimage to Jerusalem, and then, already over thirty, went back to school to learn Latin. He studied in Spain and in Paris, where he gathered a few friends. Among them was Francis Xavier, who would later carry the gospel to India and Japan, as we will see in chapter 10. In 1540 the pope approved their group as the Society of Jesus, often called the Jesuits. Ignatius led it from Rome until his death in 1556. The Jesuits started schools and missions across the world. They also worked hard to win back lands that had become Protestant, in an age when Catholics and Protestants were often bitter enemies.

The examination of conscience

At the center of Ignatius’s teaching is a simple belief: we were made for God. The first part of The Spiritual Exercises opens with these words:

“Man is created to praise, reverence, and serve God our Lord, and by this means to save his soul.”

Ignatius of Loyola, The Spiritual Exercises

If that is true, then it matters every day whether we are moving toward God or away from Him. So Ignatius taught a short prayer to be made each day, which he called the “General Examen,” the general examination of conscience. It has five steps, and it begins in a surprising place:

“The first Point is to give thanks to God our Lord for the benefits received.”

Ignatius of Loyola, The Spiritual Exercises

Only after thanks does it go on. The second step is “to ask grace to know our sins and cast them out.” The third is to look back over the day, “hour by hour, or period by period,” first at our thoughts, then our words, then our deeds. The fourth is “to ask pardon of God our Lord for the faults.” The fifth is “to purpose amendment with His grace,” that is, to decide with God’s help to do better. Then we pray the Lord’s Prayer.

This was not only for monks or scholars. In his opening notes, Ignatius said that simple exercises like these, the examen among them, suit even those who cannot read: “This way is more proper for illiterate or less educated persons.”

Notice the order. Thanks comes first, before any looking at sin. Ignatius knew from Manresa how easily an anxious person can sink into endless self-blame. The examen is not a courtroom where we accuse ourselves. It is a walk back through the day with God, who loves us and has given us every good thing in it.

A prayer for every church

Many Protestant Christians use the examen too, and it is easy to see why. Each step is drawn from Scripture. David, who began Psalm 139 by saying, “LORD, You have looked deep into me, and You know me” (Psalm 139:1), ends by asking God to look again. He does not search himself alone. He asks God to search him, because “Who can catch all their own mistakes?” (Psalm 19:12). Paul tells believers, “Look closely at yourselves” (2 Corinthians 13:5).

The English Puritans of the next century taught daily self-examination in much the same way. Ignatius joined the examen to confession before a priest, as Catholics do. Many Protestants confess to God directly, trusting His promise: “If we confess our sins, He is faithful and righteous: He will forgive our sins” (1 John 1:9). But all agree that the searching is God’s work, and that forgiveness comes through Christ. R. A. Torrey, an American Bible teacher, wrote:

“It is through prayer that my sin is brought to light, my most hidden sin.”

R. A. Torrey, How to Pray

Three key insights

  1. Looking back over the day with God begins with thanks, not with blame. Ignatius put gratitude first. When we start by counting God’s gifts, we can face our failures without fear.
  2. We cannot see our own hearts clearly, so we ask God to search them. David did not trust himself to find every fault. He invited God to look deep into him, and to guide him on the road that never ends.
  3. Noticing what draws us toward God or away from Him helps us find His way. In his sickbed Ignatius saw that some thoughts left him dry and sad, and others left him at peace with God. Paying attention to these movements, with Scripture and wise friends, helps us follow Christ.

For us today

The examen is a gift for busy and ordinary people. It needs no book, no building and no money. A bus driver in Lima can pray it on the way home. A mother in Kampala can pray it after her children are asleep. A prisoner in a cell can pray it with no light at all. Ten or fifteen minutes are enough.

It is also a gift for anxious people. Some believers spend hours worrying over their sins, as Ignatius once did. The examen gives that worry a shape and an end: thanks, light, review, forgiveness, a new start. Then we rest, because God has heard.

And it is a gift for the whole church. Catholics and Protestants have often argued about many things. But we can all kneel and pray the same psalm: “God, look deep into me and know my heart.”

Try this

Tonight, before you sleep, pray through your day with God in five steps.

  • Give thanks. Name three good gifts from today, large or small, and thank God for each.
  • Ask for light. Pray Psalm 139:23: “God, look deep into me and know my heart.”
  • Look back. Walk through the day from morning to now. Where did you feel close to God? Where did you turn away from Him in thought, word or deed?
  • Ask forgiveness and begin again. Confess what you have seen, receive Christ’s forgiveness, and ask His help for one thing tomorrow. End with the Lord’s Prayer.

A closing prayer

God, You have looked deep into me, and You know me. Thank You for every gift of this day. Thank You for Your servant Ignatius, who learned on a sickbed to notice Your work in his heart. Search me, and show me what I cannot see. Where I have turned away from You, forgive me, for the sake of Jesus Christ. Where I have walked with You, let me be glad. Free me from fear and endless self-blame, and give me grace to do better tomorrow. Look and see whether I am on a path that brings harm, and guide me along the road that never ends. Amen.

Questions for reflection

  • Why do you think Ignatius put thanksgiving first in the examen?
  • Which parts of your life do you find hardest to let God search?
  • When have you noticed that some choices leave you dry and sad, while others leave you at peace with God?

Read more on Ochorus

  • Ignatius of Loyola, The Spiritual Exercises, especially “First Week”
  • R. A. Torrey, How to Pray, especially “The Importance of Prayer”
  • Ochorus Originals, The Key Teachings of Richard Baxter, especially “Self-Examination”
Previous Next