A Mighty Fortress
The Dark Night

Chapter 8 · 9 min read · 11 min listen

The Dark Night

“Who among you fears the LORD and listens to the voice of His servant? Let the one who walks in darkness, with no glimmer of light, trust in the name of the LORD and lean on his God.” (Isaiah 50:10)

On the night of 2 December 1577, a group of men broke into a small house in Ávila, in Spain, and carried off a friar who lived there. They were not robbers. They were Carmelite friars, members of his own religious order. The prisoner was John of the Cross, a small, quiet man of thirty-five. He had joined Teresa of Ávila, whom we met in the last chapter, in her work of renewal, and the leaders of the older branch of the order saw this as disobedience. They took him to their house in Toledo, judged him and locked him up.

His prison, as later witnesses described it, was a tiny room, only a few steps long, with no window of its own. A little light came in through a small opening from the next room, and it is said that he had to stand on a bench to read his prayer book. He was given bread, water and scraps of fish, and for months he had no change of clothes. Often he was brought before the community and beaten as a punishment. Through the cold of winter and the heat of summer, he stayed in the dark.

Yet in that dark room he made poems. At first he could only keep them in his memory. Later, it is said, a kinder guard gave him paper. After about eight months, in August 1578, he escaped. The story is told that he loosened his door at night and let himself down from a window high above the river, on a rope made from strips of his blankets. He made his way to a house of Teresa’s nuns in Toledo, who hid him. There, still weak, he is said to have recited to them the poems he had made in prison.

What we know of his prison comes from what John later told his friends, written down after his death, so some details may have grown in the telling. Soon after his escape, or perhaps already in prison (scholars are not sure), he wrote a short poem that begins, in David Lewis’s old English translation: “In a dark night, / With anxious love inflamed, / O, happy lot! / Forth unobserved I went, / My house being now at rest.” The words sound like a prisoner slipping out at night. But John said they were about something deeper: the soul going out to meet God.

Who he was

John was born in 1542 in Fontiveros, a small town near Ávila. His father died when he was small, and the family was very poor. He grew up in Medina del Campo, worked in a hospital for the poor, and became a Carmelite friar and a priest. In 1567 he met Teresa, who was then about fifty-two. She asked him to help her renew the order of friars as she had begun to renew the nuns, and in 1568 he joined the first small house of the reformed friars.

It is sad that his worst suffering came from fellow Christians, and even from brothers of his own order. The quarrel was about how strictly they should live, and power and pride were mixed into it on both sides. After his escape he served as a leader and spiritual guide in southern Spain, and he died in Úbeda in 1591, aged forty-nine.

What the dark night is

Today people use the words “dark night of the soul” for any very hard time, but John meant something more exact. He wrote a book, The Dark Night of the Soul, to explain his poem. In it he describes times when God seems to take away all sweetness in prayer. The believer still loves God, but prayer feels dry and empty, and God seems far away.

John taught that such a night can be a gift. God, he says, sometimes weans the soul from sweet feelings, as a mother weans a child from milk, so that it will learn to love Him for Himself and not only for His gifts. It is God who leads the soul through the night.

He was careful, though, to say that not every dryness is this night. Dryness can come from sin, or from not caring about God, or from illness of body or mind. He gave three signs of the true night. First, the person finds no comfort “in the things of God, and none also in created things.” Second, the person keeps thinking of God with a painful worry that they are not serving Him well. A lukewarm person does not worry like that. Third, they cannot pray in the old ways, however hard they try. And John added that the lack of joy may come from “bodily indisposition or a melancholy temperament,” that is, from illness or a heavy sadness of mind.

We need this wisdom today. The dark night is not the same thing as depression. Depression is a real illness, and it often needs care from a doctor as well as from a pastor. Taking medicine for it is not a lack of faith. But the two can come together, and John himself admits that dryness may be “occasionally increased by melancholy or other infirmity.” Whatever the cause, God does not leave His children alone in the dark. When Elijah lay under a tree and asked to die, God did not scold him. An angel touched him and said, “Get up and eat, for the journey is too much for you” (1 Kings 19:7). Sometimes the most spiritual thing we can do is sleep, eat and ask for help.

Walking without light

What should we do in the night? John’s advice is gentle. “They will do enough if they keep patience, and persevere in prayer,” he writes. We should not try to force good feelings. We can simply turn our attention “lovingly and calmly towards God,” and trust that He is at work, even when we feel nothing.

That is exactly what Isaiah says. The one “who walks in darkness, with no glimmer of light,” is not told to make his own light. He is told to “trust in the name of the LORD and lean on his God.” The Bible has room for such prayers. Psalm 88 ends, “my one companion is the dark” (Psalm 88:18). And Jesus Himself cried from the cross, “My God, My God, why did You abandon Me?” (Mark 15:34). Yet He was still praying, still saying “My God.”

An American pastor of the 1800s, Richard Fuller, put it in words that D. L. Moody gathered into a book of daily readings:

“Sometimes, like Paul, you can see neither sun nor stars, and no small tempest lies on you; and then you can do but one thing; there is only one way. Reason cannot help you. Past experiences give you no light. Even prayer fetches no consolation. Only a single course is left. You must put your soul in one position and keep it there.”

Richard Fuller, in D. L. Moody, Thoughts for the Quiet Hour

Three key insights

  1. Feeling nothing in prayer is not the same as being left by God. John of the Cross found God in a prison with no window. When prayer feels empty, God may be at work most deeply, out of our sight.
  2. Not every darkness is the same, and wise love helps us tell them apart. Dryness can come from sin, from coldness, from illness or from God’s own leading. We should be honest with ourselves, and we should not be afraid to seek help from a pastor or a doctor.
  3. In the dark we are asked to lean on God, not to make our own light. Isaiah tells the one in darkness to trust and lean on God. We cannot force good feelings or make the light come back, but we can keep turning toward Him with patience.

For us today

Many believers go through times when God seems silent. A young mother in Nairobi, worn out and sad after the birth of her baby, may feel that her prayers reach no one. A pastor in China, in prison for his faith, may sit in the dark as John did. A student far from home may find that the Bible feels dry and church feels empty. None of them should conclude that God has rejected them.

It also matters how we treat others in the dark. Do not tell a suffering friend that they simply need more faith. Sit with them, pray for them when they cannot pray, and help them find a doctor if they need one.

Try this

If you are walking in darkness now, or when that time comes:

  • Pray Isaiah 50:10. Say it slowly each day: “Lord, I walk in darkness, with no glimmer of light. I will trust in Your name and lean on You.”
  • Borrow the psalmist’s words. When you have no words of your own, pray Psalm 13 or Psalm 88. God put these honest prayers in the Bible for nights like yours.
  • Tell someone. Speak to a pastor, a wise friend or, if your sadness is deep and lasting, a doctor. Asking for help is not a failure of faith.
  • Rest and eat. Remember Elijah. Care for your body as well as your soul.

A closing prayer

Lord God, even the darkness is not dark to You. Thank You for Your servant John of the Cross, who found You in a prison without light and wrote songs of love there. When prayer feels empty and You seem far away, help me to trust in Your name and lean on You. Keep me from forcing feelings, and give me patience to keep praying. Comfort all who are sad, sick or in prison tonight, and lead us through every night until we see Your face, through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.

Questions for reflection

  • Have you ever gone through a time when prayer felt dry or God seemed far away? What helped you?
  • Why do you think God sometimes allows His children to walk without light?
  • How can you care well for a friend who is in deep sadness or depression?

Read more on Ochorus

  • D. L. Moody, Thoughts for the Quiet Hour, especially “October”
  • John Wesley, Sermons on Several Occasions, especially “Heaviness through Manifold Temptations”
  • Andrew Murray, Waiting on God, especially “In Times of Darkness”
Previous Next