Chapter 17 · 9 min read · 11 min listen
“How Long, LORD?” Honest Prayer
“How long, LORD? Will You go on forgetting me for good? How long will You turn Your face away from me?” (Psalm 13:1)
We do not know what trouble David was in when he wrote Psalm 13. The psalm does not tell us. He spent years running for his life from King Saul, hiding in the hills and sleeping in caves. Later, as king, he fled from his own son Absalom. Any of those nights could have produced this prayer. Perhaps it is better that we do not know. It means the psalm can belong to anyone.
Listen to how it begins. There is no polite greeting, no “Dear Lord, thank You for this day.” It starts with a cry:
“How long, LORD?”
Then he says it again. And again. And again. Four times in two verses:
“How long, LORD? Will You go on forgetting me for good? How long will You turn Your face away from me? How long must I keep turning plans over in my mind, with grief in my heart all day long? How long will my enemy stand over me in triumph?” (Psalm 13:1-2)
Picture a man lying awake at night, turning plans over and over in his mind, finding no way out. The days have become weeks. Everyone around him seems to be winning. And the worst part is not the enemy. The worst part is that God seems to have looked away.
This is a strong thing to say to God. “Will You go on forgetting me?” David knew, as every believer knows, that God does not really forget His people. But that is how it felt, and he did not pretend otherwise.
Then the prayer turns. He stops describing his pain and starts asking:
“Turn and look, LORD my God, and answer me! Bring the light back to my eyes, or I will fall asleep in death.” (Psalm 13:3)
And then, without warning, comes a third turn. Nothing outside him has changed. The enemy is still there. No answer has come. But David says:
“But I trust in Your loyal love; my heart will be glad because You save. I will sing to the LORD, because He has been so generous to me.” (Psalm 13:5-6)
The whole psalm takes less than a minute to read. In that minute, a man walks from “How long?” to “I will sing.”
Prayers of lament
A prayer like this is called a lament. To lament means to cry out in grief. The psalms are full of them. Scholars count more laments than any other kind of psalm, perhaps a third of the whole book. That alone should tell us something. The prayer book God gave His people is not full of smiling faces. It is full of tears.
“LORD, why do You keep so far away? Why do You hide Yourself when trouble comes?” (Psalm 10:1). “Wake up, Lord! Why are You sleeping?” (Psalm 44:23). “Day and night I have fed on my tears, while all day long people ask me, ‘Where is your God?’” (Psalm 42:3). One psalm, Psalm 88, never reaches the bright turn at all. It ends with the words, “My one companion is the dark” (Psalm 88:18). Even that prayer is in the Bible.
Most laments follow the path of Psalm 13. First comes the complaint: the honest telling of what hurts. Then the request: “Turn and look, LORD my God, and answer me!” Then, very often, a turn to trust: “But I trust in Your loyal love.” Notice that the trust does not come first. David does not hide his pain behind a brave smile. He brings it all out, and then, with the pain still there, he chooses to lean on God’s love.
E. M. Bounds wrote a whole chapter on prayer and trouble. He saw how closely the two belong together:
“Trouble often drives men to God in prayer, while prayer is but the voice of men in trouble.”
E. M. Bounds, The Essentials of Prayer
Why honest prayer is faithful prayer
Some believers feel that it is wrong to complain to God. They think faith means always sounding happy. But look again at Psalm 13. David does not complain about God to other people. He complains to God. That is the difference between grumbling and lament. Grumbling walks away from God. Lament runs toward Him, even with angry, tearful words, because it still believes He is the only one who can help.
Another psalm puts it simply: “I spill out my complaint in front of Him; I tell Him all about my distress” (Psalm 142:2). You cannot spill out what you are still hiding.
Samuel Rutherford, a Scottish pastor of the 1600s who was banished from his church for a time and wrote many letters of comfort, knew how hard faith can be in the dark:
“I find it hard work to believe when the course of providence goeth cross-wise to our faith, and when misted souls in a dark night cannot know east by west, and our sea-compass seemeth to fail us. Every man is a believer in daylight: a fair day seemeth to be made all of faith and hope.”
Samuel Rutherford, Letters of Samuel Rutherford
“Every man is a believer in daylight.” The laments are prayers for the night, when our compass seems to fail. They give us words when we have none.
Where Jesus picks it up
Jesus prayed the laments of His people. In Gethsemane He told His friends, “My soul is filled with grief, grief enough to die” (Mark 14:34). Many hear in those words an echo of Psalm 42: “Why are you bent so low, my soul?” (Psalm 42:5). And on the cross, at about three in the afternoon, Jesus cried out with a loud voice the first line of Psalm 22: “My God, My God, why have You abandoned Me?” (Matthew 27:46).
The Son of God, in His darkest hour, did not invent a new prayer. He prayed a lament He had known since childhood. In those days people often named a psalm by its first line, so many believe Jesus had the whole psalm in mind. Psalm 22 begins in darkness, but it ends with praise and with “every clan of every nation” turning back to the LORD (Psalm 22:27). It ends, “He has done this!” (Psalm 22:31).
So when you pray “How long?” you are not praying alone. Your Savior has prayed in the dark before you, and so we have a high priest who can “share the feeling of our weaknesses” (Hebrews 4:15).
Three key insights
- God invites us to bring Him our real feelings, even our complaints. A great many of the psalms are laments. God put these prayers in His book so that His people would never think tears and questions are too much for Him.
- Lament is not unbelief; it is faith that refuses to walk away. Grumbling complains about God to others. Lament complains to God Himself, because it still trusts that He alone can help.
- Jesus Himself prayed the laments, so we never pray them alone. On the cross He cried the first words of Psalm 22. When we pray “How long?” we pray beside the Son who knows the dark from the inside.
For us today
Many readers of this book are living in a long “How long?” right now. A mother has buried a child. A young man has looked for work for years. A family has fled from war and lives in a camp. A believer has been in prison for the name of Jesus, and his church has prayed for his release for a long time. A widow waits for justice that does not come. To all of them the psalms say: you may tell God exactly how it feels.
In some churches, we sing only happy songs. That is a gift when life is good. But in many parts of the world, especially where believers suffer, Christians have kept the practice of lament alive. They sing their grief to God, together, and find that it does not destroy their faith. It deepens it. Every church needs room for both “I will sing” and “How long?”
And if you are not in the dark yourself, someone near you is. Lament can also be a prayer we pray with others. Sit with a grieving friend. Pray their “How long?” for them when they cannot pray it themselves.
Try this
This week, write your own lament, using Psalm 13 as your guide.
- Complain honestly. Begin with “How long, LORD?” and tell God plainly what hurts. Do not soften it.
- Ask clearly. Write a sentence like “Turn and look, LORD my God, and answer me!” Tell God what you need Him to do.
- Choose trust. End with “But I trust in Your loyal love,” and name one way God has been good to you before.
- Pray a psalm with Jesus. Read Psalm 22 slowly from beginning to end, remembering that Jesus prayed it on the cross.
A closing prayer
LORD, You know the things that make me cry, “How long?” Some nights I feel that You have forgotten me, and I do not understand Your ways. Thank You that I may tell You so. Turn and look at me, LORD my God, and answer me. Bring the light back to my eyes. Thank You, Lord Jesus, that You prayed in the dark before me, and that You know my weakness from the inside. Even now, I choose to trust in Your loyal love. My heart will be glad, because You save. Amen.
Questions for reflection
- Have you ever felt that it was wrong to tell God how you really feel? Where did that idea come from?
- What is the difference between grumbling about God and lamenting to God?
- How does it change your own prayers in the dark to know that Jesus prayed Psalm 22 on the cross?
Read more on Ochorus
- E. M. Bounds, The Essentials of Prayer, especially “Prayer and Trouble”
- Charles H. Spurgeon, Mighty Power in Prayer, especially “Prayer, the Cure for Care”
- Samuel Rutherford, Letters of Samuel Rutherford, especially “Letter CCXXIII: To Alexander Gordon of Knockgray”