Chapter 9 · 17 min read · 22 min listen
The Road to Harrowgate
This chapter is not about Wren, or Tobin, or Mira. I am sorry. They will be back very soon. But there is a part of the story that happened to somebody else, a long way off, on a road over the moors, and I cannot tell you the rest without it.
It is about the grey captain.
Captain Varrick had not slept since Cinder Hill.
That is not quite true. He had slept, a little, in snatches: on his horse, sometimes, with his chin on his chest, or sitting up against a wall in a burned barn with his sword across his knees. A quarter of an hour. Half an hour. But whenever he slept, he dreamed; and whenever he dreamed, he saw the same thing. A man walking up a black hill at dawn, carrying nothing, with the colour coming back into the ash behind him where he walked. And the man’s hands.
So he had stopped sleeping, as far as he could, and taken to riding instead.
He rode now at the head of his column on the old drove-road over the Harrowgate Highlands, in the grey middle of the morning, with the moors going away on every side of him under a low sky. Heather, grey as old wool. Stone walls running up and over the hills and down again. Sheep, grey, that lifted their heads and stared as the column went by and then put them down again. Far off, a grey tarn like a coin dropped in a field. The road was a pale stony track worn between banks of peat, and it went on ahead of him over the next rise and the next, towards the town of Harrowgate and the coast and the black water beyond it.
Behind him rode twenty of his Knights, in pairs, as always. Behind them walked the prisoners.
There were fourteen today. He did not look round at them. He did not need to. He could hear them: the shuffle of their feet on the stones, and the creak and jingle of the buckled rope that joined their wrists, and now and then, from somewhere in the middle of the line, a child crying, very quietly, and being hushed. Farmers. A cobbler and his wife. A boy with a bandaged head. An old woman. Remnant folk, every one, taken from a barn at Low Coombe four nights ago where somebody had carved a little flame over the door.
And behind them, at the end of the column, the Knight with the sack.
He could feel it from here. That was the worst of it. He could feel it on the back of his neck the whole way: the sack, slung across the last Knight’s saddle, bulging with the lamps they had taken from the barns. There were nearly thirty in it now. Bright brass lamps, new, undented, with no wicks, burning — still burning, every one, through the sacking, a soft gold glow showing through the weave like a lantern with a cloth over it. They had been burning since the first barn. They would not go out. He had tried. He had thrown water on the sack. He had buried it overnight in a peat-bog. In the morning, when the Knight dug it up, it was warm.
And it was heavy. Much heavier than thirty small brass lamps had any right to be. The horse that carried it had gone lame twice.
He should leave it. He knew that. He should leave it in a ditch on the moor and ride on and never think of it again. But the Queen wanted them. Bring me every one, she had said, in the voice like warm milk going cold. Every one they carry. I want to see them. And so he carried them, east, towards the sea, with the warmth of them on the back of his neck like a hand.
He rubbed his palm.
He did not know he was doing it. He had done it for thirty years, and never once noticed.
He was thinking, as he rode, about tea.
He did not want to think about tea. He wanted to think about the road, and the weather, and the time it would take to reach Harrowgate, and the boats at Skerrow, and what he would say to the Queen. He had been very good, for thirty years, at thinking about the things he wanted to think about. It was one of the first things she had taught him.
But since Cinder Hill it had not worked. Things came into his head that he had not put there. And this morning, riding over the grey moor, it was tea.
Dreadful tea. Tea so stewed and black and bitter, made in a pot so old and so seldom washed, that it tasted like a boot that had been boiled in a puddle. He had said exactly that, once, out loud. Thirty years ago. In a crooked tower on a wall, with a cracked cup in his hands, to a tall old man who was not so old then.
Hm, the old man had said, and poured him another cup.
His name — but no. He did not think his name. He had not thought it for thirty years. It was not a thing he did.
He thought instead, because he could not stop it, about the wall.
The North Wall of Emberwick, at night, at the turning of the night, with the Ring-lamps burning — yellow, then, not gold; the Guild had already started watering the oil — and the wind coming off the Greywaste; and a boy of nineteen walking along the wall-walk behind a tall old man with a brass-hooked pole. Learning the lamps. Learning the wicks. Learning the old words. Though I walk through the gloaming. The old man had been not so old then. His beard had been grey, not white. But he had already been saying Hm.
He thought about the oath.
He thought about kneeling on the stone floor of the Leaning Tower, with his right hand held out flat over a little brass bowl in which a flame was burning — the oath-fire of the Lamplighters, the last little ember of it, kept alive in that tower for longer than anybody could remember, so old and so low that it was nearly out. And the old man’s voice, quite quiet: Will you give it freely? To anyone who asks? And never charge a penny, as long as you live? And his own voice, very young, very sure: I will. And the old man taking his hand, and laying it palm down in the flame.
It had not hurt. That was the strange thing. It ought to have hurt. It had left a scar right across his palm that he had carried for thirty years. But at the time it had only been warm, like putting your hand on a cat.
Then you’re a Lamplighter, lad, the old man had said. Hm. Welcome.
He rubbed his palm.
And then he thought, because he could not stop it, about the night it all went wrong.
He did not think about it as a story. It was not a story. It was just a handful of pictures, sharp as broken glass. The Guild Hall, gilded, full of lamplight and lavender. The Masters of the Guild in their gold chains, at their long table. The old man standing in front of them in his patched blue coat, with his pole, saying No. I will not charge for it. Not a penny. It was given. And the Guild Master — not Prowle; the one before him, a long thin man with a voice like a door creaking — smiling, and saying Then you are no longer a member of this Guild.
And nothing happened.
That was what he remembered most. That nothing happened. He had stood at the back of the Guild Hall, nineteen years old, with his oath-scar still pink on his palm, and waited for something to happen. For the lamps to go out. For the Flame to do something. For the Lampwright himself to come walking in out of the old stories and set the Guild Hall on fire. Anything. And nothing had. The old man had simply turned round, and walked out of the Guild Hall, and gone back to his crooked tower on the wall, and gone on lighting lamps that the Guild let go dim, one at a time, every night, for nothing, while the whole city laughed at him.
And the boy had stood in the street outside, in the cold, and thought: it’s useless. It’s a candle against the sea. It does nothing. It will never do anything. And he had wanted, more than he had ever wanted anything, a power that would do something.
And a voice had spoken to him in the dark. Very kindly. Like warm milk going cold.
I can give you that, it had said.
He had served her thirty years.
He had been good at it. He had been the best she had. He had learned the offer, which was her favourite weapon: you never had to fight people if you could only find the thing they wanted most and offer it to them on the wrong terms. He had offered Lord Edric Harrowgate a seat at a larger table. He had offered Oskar Venn a world without Guilds. He had offered a sweep-girl on a burning tower her life and a full belly, and a boy in a lighthouse his father, and he had taken a lamp from that boy’s burned hands and laughed. He had stood in the Forge under Vaelport and watched the old man hold the door — his old master, white-bearded now, lame, leaning on two poles — and heard him say lad, and hesitated for one long heartbeat.
And then chosen.
And then the tunnel had fallen.
And he had told himself, all the way back across the coast hills, that it was finished. That the old man was dead, and the lamp would follow, and he would never have to hear that voice say lad again.
And then, on a black hill at dawn, a stranger had come walking up out of the Burned Country with the pale sun behind him; and the Queen had screamed; and the Hollow Knights had fallen back like shadows from a lamp; and he — Varrick — had stood his ground the longest of all, because he did not believe it, because it could not be. And he had looked at the stranger’s hands.
They had scars on them. Old round deep scars, like burns.
And he had looked down at his own right palm. At his own scar. The oath-scar. The one the old man had given him in the little brass bowl.
It was the same shape.
He rubbed his palm. He rubbed it until it hurt.
“Faster,” he said to the Knight beside him, though the Knight could not hear him and would not have cared; the Knights did not care about anything. He kicked his horse on. He drove the whole column on over the moor, harder, faster, so that the prisoners stumbled on the stones behind him and the child stopped crying because it had no breath left to cry with. He would go faster than the tea, and the wall, and the oath, and the hands. He would get to Harrowgate by nightfall and Skerrow by tomorrow and the black water by the day after, and he would give the Queen her lamps and her prisoners and then he would sleep, at last, in the grey, where nothing came into your head that you did not put there.
It is easier in the grey, said the Queen’s voice in his head, softly. Lie down. It is easier.
Lad, said the old man.
He rode faster.
It was noon when it happened.
It was noon on the high moor, the highest part of the road, where it ran along a ridge between two long shallow valleys with tarns in them, and there was nothing in any direction but grey heather and grey sky. The pale sun was as high as it ever went, which was not high, a dull coin in the cloud. There was no wind.
And then there was light.
It did not come from the sun. He knew that at once. It did not come from anywhere. It was simply there, all round him, all at once, as if somebody had opened a door in the middle of the moor and the whole of the inside of the world had come pouring out. It was gold. It was white. It was so bright that the heather went to nothing and the road went to nothing and the sky went to nothing, and he could not see his horse’s ears in front of him or his own hands on the reins.
And it was warm.
It was so warm. It was like being inside the Flame. It was like being inside the little brass bowl on the floor of the Leaning Tower, with his palm laid flat in it, thirty years ago; except that it was not his palm now. It was all of him.
His horse screamed and reared and he went off it backwards into the heather. He hit the ground hard, on his back, and lay there, and the light did not stop.
He heard his Knights’ horses bolting. He heard the prisoners cry out — not in fear; in astonishment. He heard the sack at the back of the column burst, a ripping of sacking, and a sound like thirty small breaths let out at once. Ah.
And then he heard a voice.
He knew it. That was the dreadful thing; that was the thing he had been riding from since the spring. He had never heard it before in his life, and he knew it the way you know your own name. It was low, and warm, and a little rough, like a man who laughs a good deal. It was not angry. It was very close. It might have been kneeling beside him in the heather.
“Aren,” it said. “Why are you hunting me?”
Nobody had called him that for thirty years.
He tried to speak. His mouth would not work. He lay on his back in the blazing light with his eyes wide open and seeing nothing, and his scarred right hand was burning — not hurting; burning, the way it had in the brass bowl, warm all the way through — and at last he got out two words, in a voice he did not recognise as his own. A boy’s voice. Nineteen.
“Who are you?”
He knew. He knew perfectly well. But he had to ask.
“I’m the one you’re hunting,” said the voice. “Every lamp in that sack is mine. Every one of those people on your rope is mine. Every barn you burned had my flame over the door.” A pause. Not angry. Almost — he could not believe it — almost gentle. “You were mine first, lad. Before any of them.”
He lay in the heather and wept.
He had not wept for thirty years either. It came out of him the way water comes out of a cracked dam: all at once, everywhere, with nothing to stop it. He lay on his back on the moor and wept like a child, and the light went on and on, and the warmth went on, and the voice did not say anything for a long time, only waited, the way the old man used to wait on the wall when a wick would not catch.
“Get up,” it said at last. Kindly. “Go into the town. You’ll be told what to do.”
He got up.
The light had gone. He knew it had gone, because the warmth had gone with it, except in his palm. He could hear the wind, now — a little moor wind, getting up, cold, smelling of peat. He could hear sheep somewhere. He could hear, a long way off, the Knights’ horses still galloping.
But he could not see.
He stood on the road with his eyes open, and there was nothing. Not grey. Not dark. Nothing. As if the light had been so bright that it had burned the seeing right out of him, the way you look at the sun too long and see only a black hole where it was. He put his hands up to his face. He could feel his eyes, open. He could not see his hands.
He stood there for a long time, swaying, in the middle of the drove-road on the high moor, alone.
Then he heard feet.
They came towards him slowly over the stones. Several people. They stopped a little way off. Nobody said anything. He could hear them breathing.
“Who’s there?” he said.
His voice was hoarse. It was not smooth any more. It was not oiled iron. It was only a man’s voice.
Nobody answered for a long time. Then a woman spoke — a Highland voice, low and frightened and very careful, the way you speak near a dog that has bitten.
“It’s us,” she said. “From Low Coombe. From the barn.” A pause. “The ropes burned through. All at once. In the light. They just — fell off.” Another pause. “Your Knights have gone. Off over the moor, like smoke. There’s nobody here but us.”
He did not say anything. There was nothing to say.
“The lamps came out of the sack,” said the woman. “They’re lying in the heather. All of them. Burning.” Her voice wobbled. “We picked them up. They’re ours.”
“Yes,” he said. “They’re yours.”
Another long silence. He could hear them whispering. He could hear a child, the one who had been crying all morning, asking a question in a small voice; and being hushed. He waited for them to go. He did not blame them. He waited for a stone, or a blow, or simply the sound of their feet going away down the road towards Harrowgate, leaving him blind on the moor with the wind getting up; and he thought he would not mind very much. He thought it would be fair.
The feet came closer instead.
One pair. Slowly. They stopped right in front of him.
And a hand took his hand.
It was a woman’s hand, small and hard and work-rough, with the marks of a loom on the fingers; and it was shaking. She had been roped to the others by the wrist for four days, behind his horse. He could feel the raw rope-burn on her wrist against his own. And she took his scarred right hand in hers, and held it, the way you hold the hand of somebody who cannot see where they are going.
“Come on, then,” she said. Her voice was shaking too. “It’s not far. It’s — I’ll take you. Mind the stones.”
And so it was the people he had captured who led their captor into Harrowgate, by the hand, in the grey afternoon: fourteen Remnant folk from a burned barn at Low Coombe, with thirty lamps burning gold in their arms, walking slowly down the drove-road off the high moor, and in the middle of them a tall grey blind man in grey armour, who stumbled on the stones, and did not let go.
That night, in a dark room in a house at the end of a street in a town he could not see, he lay on a straw mattress with his eyes open, and did not sleep, and did not want to.
He thought about tea. He thought about the wall. He thought about a voice in the heather, not angry. About his palm, which was still warm.
And then — for the first time in thirty years, very quietly, in the dark, to nobody at all — he said his own name out loud.
“Aren.”