The Fire on the Altar
Little Churches Within the Church

Chapter 3 · 9 min read · 11 min listen

Little Churches Within the Church

“Then those who feared the LORD talked with one another, and the LORD listened and heard them. A book of remembrance was written in His presence about those who feared the LORD and honored His name.” (Malachi 3:16)

In the summer of 1670, in the German city of Frankfurt, a few men came to their pastor with a request. Frankfurt was a busy trading city on the river Main. The pastor was Philipp Jakob Spener, the senior minister of the Lutheran churches there. He was thirty-five years old, a careful scholar and a warm preacher.

The men wanted more than sermons. They wanted to meet together during the week, to talk about the things of God and to help one another live as Christians. Spener hesitated. He knew that in other places such private meetings had led people to break away from the church, and he did not want that. But he also saw their hunger. So he agreed, on one condition: they would meet in his own house, and he would be with them.

So a small group began to gather in Spener’s study, twice a week. At first only a few men came. Spener opened with prayer and read aloud from a devotional book. Then they talked freely together about what they had heard. There were rules. They were to speak only of what would build up faith and godliness. They were not to argue for the sake of arguing. They were not to talk about people who were not there. If they spoke of the sins of the church or the town, they were to speak in general, without naming names.

The group grew. Later the doors were opened to women and to ordinary working people as well as to the learned. After a few years they set aside the other books and read the Bible itself. Spener called these meetings by a Latin name, collegia pietatis, which means “gatherings for godliness.” He also spoke of them as ecclesiola in ecclesia, “a little church within the church.” He did not want them to leave their parish churches. He wanted them to bring new life into them.

Who he was

Spener was born in 1635 in Alsace, on the border of France and Germany, while the Thirty Years’ War was still burning across the land. As a young man he read Johann Arndt’s True Christianity, and English Puritan books such as Lewis Bayly’s The Practice of Piety, which had been translated into German. These books taught him that faith is not only right belief but a new heart and a changed life.

When the war ended in 1648, much of Germany lay in ruins. The Lutheran churches had kept the true teaching of the gospel, and they were rightly proud of it. But Spener saw that in many places faith had grown cold. Pastors argued about fine points of doctrine. Many church members heard the sermon with their ears, he said, but it never reached their hearts. Drunkenness was common, and so were lawsuits between neighbors. People went to church, took Holy Communion and went home unchanged.

Malachi lived in a time something like that. The people of Judah had come back from exile and rebuilt the temple. But they had grown tired and bitter. They said, “It is useless to serve God” (Malachi 3:14). Then something quiet happened. A few people who still feared the LORD began to talk with one another. They did not start a war or a new nation. They simply met and spoke about God. And the LORD listened. He heard them, and He had their names written in a book of remembrance.

Heartfelt longings

In 1675 Spener was asked to write a preface for a new edition of Arndt’s sermons. What he wrote was so important that it was soon printed as a little book of its own. It is called Pia Desideria, which means “Pious Desires” or “Heartfelt Longings.” In it he grieved over the state of the church. But he also wrote with hope. He believed that God could make His church better, and he offered some simple proposals.

The book is not in the Ochorus library, and the good English translations of it are modern, so we will describe his ideas in our own words.

First, Spener urged that God’s word be used far more widely among the people: read at home, read in the gatherings, talked about together, not only heard on Sunday. Second, he reminded the church of something Luther had taught: every believer is a priest. Peter calls the whole church “a royal priesthood” (1 Peter 2:9). This does not do away with pastors, Spener said. But it means every Christian is called to pray for others, to teach and encourage the household, and to warn and comfort fellow believers. Third, he insisted that knowing the Christian faith is not enough. It must be practiced, above all in love.

His fourth proposal is one we still need. When Christians disagree, he wrote, they should argue with humility and love, not to defeat one another but to help one another toward the truth. They should pray for those who are in error. The last proposals were for the training of pastors: they should be godly as well as learned, and they should preach to build up faith in ordinary people, not to show off their learning.

More than two hundred years later, Andrew Murray put Spener’s third point in a way that goes straight to the heart of prayer:

“Not according to what I try to be when praying, but what I am when not praying, is my prayer dealt with by God.”

Andrew Murray, With Christ in the School of Prayer

Light and shadow

The little gatherings spread to other towns in Germany. People who joined them were soon given a nickname by their critics: “Pietists,” the pious ones. At first the name was meant as mockery. In time they wore it gladly.

There were real dangers, and Spener knew it. Some groups grew proud. They began to think of themselves as the only true Christians and of their neighbors as lost. Some left the church altogether. In Frankfurt itself, a few of the first members broke away. Later, in Dresden and Berlin, Spener no longer led such meetings himself, and gave more of his effort to teaching the catechism to the young. He was attacked fiercely by other Lutheran theologians, who accused him of many errors. He answered his critics and stayed in the church he loved until his death in 1705.

His influence went far beyond his own life. He helped a young scholar named August Hermann Francke, whom we will meet in the next chapter. And Nikolaus Ludwig von Zinzendorf, who met Spener as a boy at his grandmother’s home, later shaped the Moravian village of Herrnhut as another “church within the church.” The small groups, house fellowships and cell groups that meet in homes around the world today owe more to Spener’s little gatherings than most of them know.

Three key insights

  1. When believers who fear God talk together about Him, the Lord listens and remembers. Malachi’s friends did not do anything the world would notice. They met and spoke of God. God listened, and their names were written before Him.
  2. A small group stays healthy when it builds others up instead of tearing them down. Spener’s rules were simple: speak only what helps faith, do not argue for victory, and do not talk about those who are absent. Without love, even a prayer meeting can become a place of pride and division.
  3. Because every believer is a priest, praying for others belongs to the whole church, not only to the pastor. Peter calls the whole church a royal priesthood. A mother, a farmer or a student can pray for others, open the Scriptures with them and comfort them in trouble.

For us today

In many parts of the world, the church grows most in small groups. In China, believers have long met in homes, often without a building or a trained pastor. In Nigeria, Brazil and Korea, cell groups gather in apartments and courtyards on weeknights. Spener’s little gatherings speak to all of them.

His rules speak to us too. It is easy for a fellowship group to slide into gossip, or into arguments about things that do not build anyone up. It is easy to feel that our little group is better than the big church down the road. Spener wanted the opposite: little churches that would bring life back into the whole church.

And Malachi reminds us that no meeting is too small for God to notice. Three believers talking about Jesus over a cup of tea are heard in heaven.

Try this

This week, try a little gathering for godliness.

  • Invite two or three. Ask one or two believing friends, neighbors or family members to meet with you once this week for half an hour.
  • Open the word together. Read a short passage, such as Malachi 3:16-18 or 1 Peter 2:4-10. Let each person say one thing they notice.
  • Keep Spener’s rules. Agree together: speak only to build up, do not argue to win, and do not talk about anyone who is not there.
  • Pray for one another by name. Before you part, let each person pray for the one beside them.

A closing prayer

Lord God, You listen when those who fear You speak together, and You remember their names. Thank You for Your servant Philipp Spener and for the little gatherings that brought new life to Your church. Give me friends who love You, and make me a friend who helps them. Guard our words from gossip and pride. Let us read Your word together and live what we read. Make every one of us a faithful priest, praying for others and pointing them to Christ. And renew Your whole church, in every land, through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.

Questions for reflection

  • Malachi’s friends met when others said, “It is useless to serve God.” Where do you hear that kind of discouragement today, and who could you talk with about God instead?
  • Which of Spener’s rules for his gatherings would most help the groups you belong to?
  • What does it mean for you that every believer is a priest? Whom could you pray for and encourage this week?

Read more on Ochorus

  • Andrew Murray, With Christ in the School of Prayer, especially “Prayer and Love” and “The Power of United Prayer”
  • D. L. Moody, Prevailing Prayer, especially “Unity”
Previous Next