The Fire on the Altar
Pulled from Their Knees

Chapter 15 · 9 min read · 12 min listen

Pulled from Their Knees

“There is no Jew or Greek, there is no slave or free person, there is no male and female, for all of you are one in Christ Jesus.” (Galatians 3:28)

It was a Sunday morning in Philadelphia, at St George’s Methodist Church on Fourth Street. Black and white Methodists worshiped there together. The Black members had given money toward the church’s new gallery, an upper floor around the inside walls, and toward laying new floors.

As more Black worshipers came, the leaders grew uneasy and moved them from their usual seats to places around the walls. Then, on this Sunday, the sexton (the man who kept the building) met them at the door and told them to go up to the gallery. Richard Allen, a preacher who had once been a slave, tells what happened next:

“We expected to take the seats over the ones we formerly occupied below, not knowing any better. We took those seats. Meeting had begun, and they were nearly done singing, and just as we got to the seats, the elder said, ‘let us pray.’ We had not been long upon our knees before I heard considerable scuffling and low talking.”

Richard Allen, The Life, Experience, and Gospel Labours

Allen raised his head. One of the trustees, the men who managed the church’s property, had hold of his friend Absalom Jones and was “pulling him up off of his knees.” “You must get up,” the trustee said, “you must not kneel here.” Jones did not fight. He asked only to finish praying: “wait until prayer is over, and I will get up and trouble you no more.” The trustee refused and called another trustee, who went to pull up a third man, William White.

Allen writes: “By this time prayer was over, and we all went out of the church in a body, and they were no more plagued with us in the church.”

We have this story in Allen’s own account of his life, published in 1833, two years after his death. He gives no date. It was long placed in 1787; many historians now think it happened around 1792, when the gallery was built. The date is still debated.

Who they were

Absalom Jones was born into slavery in Delaware in 1746. At sixteen he was brought to Philadelphia, where he worked in his owner’s shop and was allowed to attend a night school run by the Quaker teacher Anthony Benezet. First he bought the freedom of his wife, Mary, so that their children would be born free. Then, in 1784, he gained his own freedom.

Richard Allen was born into slavery in Philadelphia in 1760 and grew up on a farm in Delaware. He came to faith through Methodist preachers, bought his freedom, and became a traveling preacher. In 1786 he came back to Philadelphia, preached at St George’s, sometimes at five o’clock in the morning, and started prayer meetings among the city’s Black people. In 1787 he and Jones founded the Free African Society, in which free Black people paid small amounts each month to help one another in sickness and to care for widows and orphans.

After the day at St George’s, the two friends went different ways, but in peace. Most of the group joined the Episcopal Church and in July 1794 opened St Thomas’s African Episcopal Church, with Jones as pastor. In 1802 he became the first Black priest of the Episcopal Church in America. Allen would not leave the Methodists, who had first brought him the gospel. He bought an old blacksmith’s shop, hauled it to a lot he owned, and made it a church. It opened in July 1794, and it was named Bethel, “house of God,” after the place where Jacob said, “This is God’s own house, and here is the doorway into heaven” (Genesis 28:17).

For years white Methodist leaders tried to take control of Bethel. In 1816 the courts ruled for the congregation, and that same year Black Methodist churches from several cities formed the African Methodist Episcopal Church, with Allen as its first bishop. Mother Bethel still stands on the same ground, and the AME Church now has members on several continents.

How they prayed

The trustees did not stop these men in the street. They stopped them in church, on their knees, in the middle of prayer, the one place where every believer should be welcome. Paul wrote that in Christ “there is no slave or free person ... for all of you are one in Christ Jesus” (Galatians 3:28). James warned churches not to say to one person, “Take this good seat here,” and to another, “Sit on the floor down by my footstool” (James 2:3). When a Methodist elder later threatened to put them out of the church, they answered him:

“We told him we had no place of worship; and we did not mean to go to St. George’s church any more, as we were so scandalously treated in the presence of all the congregation present; ‘and if you deny us your name, you cannot seal up the scriptures from us, and deny us a name in heaven. We believe heaven is free for all who worship in spirit and truth.’”

Richard Allen, The Life, Experience, and Gospel Labours

Their answer to injustice was prayer joined to action. On the day they began to dig the cellar for the new church, Allen writes, “I arose early in the morning and addressed the throne of grace, praying that the Lord would bless our endeavours.”

In the late summer of 1793 yellow fever swept through Philadelphia. Thousands died, and all who could afford it fled. Doctors and city leaders asked Black Philadelphians for help, partly because people wrongly believed they could not catch the disease. Jones and Allen met to decide what to do, put their trust in God and agreed to go. In a pamphlet they wrote together in 1794 they said: “The Lord was pleased to strengthen us, and remove all fear from us, and disposed our hearts to be as useful as possible.” For weeks they nursed the sick, buried the dead and gathered up orphaned children. They were not protected from the fever, and many Black helpers caught it.

When a printer named Mathew Carey (no relation of the William Carey of chapter 17) accused Black nurses of overcharging the sick, Jones and Allen answered him firmly, with facts. But in the same pamphlet they printed an address to slaveholders. It reminded them that Jesus commands us to love our enemies, and then it said:

“I feel the obligations, I wish to impress them on the minds of our colored brethren, and that we may all forgive you, as we wish to be forgiven, we think it a great mercy to have all anger and bitterness removed from our minds; I appeal to your own feelings, if it is not very disquiting to feel yourselves under dominion of wrathful disposition.”

Richard Allen, The Life, Experience, and Gospel Labours

They asked God to remove their anger as a “great mercy” to themselves. That is not weakness. It is a heart set free from hatred.

Three key insights

  1. Every believer has the same right to kneel before God, because all are one in Christ Jesus. The trustees tried to decide who could pray where. But God had already decided. The ground at the foot of the cross is level, and no one may push another off it.
  2. Prayer can give the wronged the courage to act, not only the strength to endure. Jones and Allen did not stay where they were not wanted. They prayed, walked out together, and built two churches. In the fever, prayer took away their fear so that they could serve.
  3. Forgiving those who wronged us does not mean pretending the wrong was small. Allen named the injustice plainly and answered false charges with the truth. Yet he asked God to take all bitterness from his heart, and offered forgiveness to those who held his people in chains.

For us today

Christians have treated other Christians this way in many lands, keeping them apart by race, caste, tribe or class, even at the Lord’s Table. Some readers have been the ones pushed aside. Others belong to churches that did the pushing. The story of St George’s asks all of us to look honestly at our own congregations. Who is quietly sent upstairs?

For those who have been wronged, Allen and Jones show a way between bitterness and silence. In Johannesburg or São Paulo, in Indian villages where Dalit believers are still kept apart, in a city church where migrants feel unwanted, believers can name the wrong, pray, and build something better without letting hatred rule their hearts. And the yellow fever teaches us all: the people a city despised were the ones who stayed to care for it.

Try this

This week, let Allen and Jones teach you to pray for a church where all are one.

  • Pray Galatians 3:28. Read it slowly each morning, and thank God for believers of other races, tribes and nations whom He has made your brothers and sisters.
  • Look around your church. Ask God to show you who is left out or kept at the edges, and then go and sit with them.
  • Bring your anger to God. If you have been wronged, tell God plainly what happened. Then ask Him, as Allen did, for the “great mercy” of a heart set free from bitterness.

A closing prayer

Lord Jesus Christ, You welcome every sinner who comes to You, and You make us one family in Yourself. Thank You for Absalom Jones, who was pulled from his knees, and Richard Allen, who walked out beside him, and for how they still kept praying, who built houses of prayer and served a city that despised them. Forgive Your church for every time we have pushed others aside, even at prayer. When I am wronged, give me courage to speak the truth and grace to forgive. Take away my fear, so that I can serve the sick and the forgotten. Make Your church one, so that the world may believe. Amen.

Questions for reflection

  • Absalom Jones asked only to finish his prayer. Why do you think the trustees would not wait? What does that tell us about prejudice?
  • How did Allen and Jones answer injustice without becoming bitter? Which part of their answer is hardest for you?
  • Are there people who are kept at the edges of your church or community? What could you do this week to change that?

Read more on Ochorus

  • Richard Allen, The Life, Experience, and Gospel Labours, especially “The Life of Richard Allen” and “A Narrative of the Proceedings of the Coloured People”
  • Ochorus Originals, They Were Young – Book 1: Called, especially “Richard Allen: The Night the Dungeon Shook”
Previous Next