The Fire on the Altar
Praying in the Snow

Chapter 11 · 9 min read · 11 min listen

Praying in the Snow

“My children, I am suffering birth pains over you a second time, and I will until Christ is formed in you.” (Galatians 4:19)

In April 1743 a thin young preacher of twenty-four rode into a place called Kaunaumeek, in the forest between Stockbridge in Massachusetts and Albany in New York. A small community of Mahican people lived there, and he had been sent to tell them about Christ. His name was David Brainerd. On his first night he slept, as he wrote in his diary, “on a little heap of straw, in a log room without any floor.”

He stayed almost a year. For a time he lived with the people in one of their wigwams, and then he built a small house of his own. Bread had to be fetched from ten or fifteen miles away, and sometimes it was moldy before he could eat it. That winter he was told to learn the language from John Sergeant, the missionary at Stockbridge, so he rode back and forth again and again. Jonathan Edwards, who later edited his diary, explains that these rides took him “twenty miles through the uninhabited woods between Stockbridge and Kaunaumeek; which many times exposed him to extreme hardship in the severe seasons of the winter.” Brainerd himself looked back on those months and wrote: “I have been often exposed to cold and hunger in the wilderness, where the comforts of life were not to be had; have frequently been lost in the woods; and sometimes obliged to ride much of the night; and once lay out in the woods all night.”

The diary does not describe one famous night of kneeling in the snow. The title of this chapter is a picture of those hard winters, and of what Brainerd did in them. Again and again his entries begin the same way: he went out into the woods to pray. “I love to live alone in my own little cottage,” he wrote that November, “where I can spend much time in prayer.”

Two years later, in the summer of 1745, he came to a settlement of Lenape (Delaware) people at Crossweeksung, in New Jersey. On 8 August he preached to about sixty-five men, women and children. He wrote that evening:

“There was much visible concern among them while I was discoursing publicly; but afterward, when I spoke to one and another more particularly, whom I perceived under much concern, the power of God seemed to descend upon the assembly ‘like a mighty rushing wind,’ and with an astonishing energy bore down all before it.”

David Brainerd, The Life and Diary of David Brainerd

Old men and women, and children of six or seven, cried to God for mercy. Brainerd noticed that each one seemed to be praying alone, though they were all in one house: “every one praying apart, although all together.”

Who he was

David Brainerd was born in 1718 in Haddam, Connecticut. His father died when he was nine and his mother when he was about fourteen. In July 1739, walking alone in a quiet place, he found peace with God through Christ. He went to Yale College in the years of the Great Awakening, but in 1742 he was expelled, partly because he had said of one of his tutors that he had “no more grace than this chair.” The words were careless and unkind, and he later asked to be forgiven for them. Yale still refused him his degree.

A Scottish missionary society then sent him to the Native peoples of New York, Pennsylvania and New Jersey. Like many settlers of his time, he used harsh words for them in his diary, words that hurt to read today. Yet he loved them, and it grieved him that many settlers, as he wrote, had “no regard to the souls of the poor Indians.”

He was also a man of deep sadness. Edwards did not hide it. In his preface he wrote:

“There is one thing, easily discernible in the life of Brainerd, which by many may be considered an objection to the extraordinary evidences of his religion and devotion, viz. that he was, by his constitution and natural temper, so prone to melancholy and dejection of Spirit.”

Jonathan Edwards, The Life and Diary of David Brainerd

(Melancholy is an old word for deep and lasting low spirits.) Edwards added, gently, that Brainerd also worked too hard and did not care for his body. He had tuberculosis, a disease of the lungs. In 1747, too ill to work, he came to Edwards’s house in Northampton, Massachusetts. Edwards’s daughter Jerusha nursed him. He died there on 9 October 1747, aged twenty-nine. Jerusha died a few months later. In 1749 Edwards published Brainerd’s life and diary, and it has sent missionaries into all the world ever since.

How he prayed

Brainerd’s diary is full of prayer, much of it for other people. Before he ever became a missionary, on 14 June 1742, he set apart a day for fasting and prayer. Near evening, he wrote:

“I wrestled for absent friends, for the ingathering of souls, for multitudes of poor souls, and for many that I thought were the children of God, in many distant places. I was in such an agony, from half an hour before sunset, till near dark, that I was all over wet with sweat: but yet it seemed to me that I had wasted away the day, and had done nothing.”

David Brainerd, The Life and Diary of David Brainerd

Ingathering means bringing in the harvest. He longed to see many people brought to Christ, as a farmer longs to see the crop brought home.

This is what Paul meant when he wrote of “birth pains” in our key verse (Galatians 4:19). A mother cannot make her baby be born by trying harder. But she cannot be calm and careless about it either. Paul loved the Galatians so much that their need for Christ hurt him. Edwards used the same picture of Brainerd: after years of “agonizing in prayer, and travailing in birth for their conversion,” he wrote, “at length the day dawns.”

Notice too what Brainerd felt afterward: he thought he “had done nothing.” Prayer often feels like that. His sad moods often told him that he was useless. But God was not measuring his prayers by his feelings. Brainerd prayed in 1742 for “multitudes” in “distant places.” In 1745, in a place he had never planned to go, God answered.

His prayers were also humble. In his last months at Northampton, Edwards noticed that he “generally made it one petition in his prayer, ‘that we might not outlive our usefulness.’”

Three key insights

  1. Longing prayer for others is a kind of birth pain, and God uses it to bring new life. Paul suffered birth pains for the Galatians, and Brainerd wrestled in prayer for people he had not yet met. We cannot make anyone believe, but love that aches in prayer is never wasted.
  2. A believer who struggles with sadness can still be a mighty intercessor. Brainerd’s moods were often dark, and Edwards said so honestly. Yet God heard his prayers and used his life. Our feelings are not the measure of our usefulness to God.
  3. The answer to long prayer may come at a time and place we never expected. Brainerd prayed for years with little to show for it. Then, among people he had not planned to visit, the Spirit came “like a mighty rushing wind.” Edwards said it came “at a time, in a place, and upon subjects, that scarce ever entered his heart.”

For us today

Many believers today carry a burden of prayer for people who do not yet know Christ: a son who has left the faith, neighbors of another religion, a people group in a distant land. Some pray in places where preaching is forbidden. Some pray for years and see nothing. Brainerd’s story says: keep praying. The birth pains are not the end of the story.

His story also speaks to those who struggle with depression. In many churches, in Africa, Asia, Latin America and the West, people still whisper that a sad Christian must have weak faith. Brainerd’s life says otherwise. If you carry that heaviness, you are not alone, and you are not useless to God. But learn from his mistakes too. Rest, eat, sleep and accept help, as Brainerd accepted Jerusha’s care at the end. Your body is not your enemy. And if someone near you is struggling, be a Jerusha to them.

Try this

This week, let your love for others become prayer.

  • Name your harvest. Write down the names of three people who do not yet know Christ, and pray for them by name each day.
  • Find a quiet place. Brainerd went into the woods. Find your own place: a field, a rooftop, a corner of a room, a walk at dawn.
  • Pray when you feel useless. On a day when you feel you have done nothing, offer God that feeling, and pray for someone else anyway.
  • Care for a tired servant. Think of a pastor, missionary or caregiver who is worn out, and give them a meal, a visit or a day of rest.

A closing prayer

Lord Jesus, You poured out Your soul in prayer for us, and You still pray for us at the Father’s right hand. Thank You for Your servant David Brainerd, who prayed in the cold woods for people he did not yet know, and for the Lenape believers of Crossweeksung, who cried out to You together. Give me a heart that aches for others until Christ is formed in them. When my spirit is heavy and I feel I have done nothing, hold me fast and teach me to keep praying. Send Your Spirit like a mighty wind on the places I pray for, in Your time and in Your way. Amen.

Questions for reflection

  • Paul felt “birth pains” for the Galatians. Is there anyone for whom you feel that kind of longing in prayer? If not, whom could you begin to carry?
  • Brainerd often felt that he had “done nothing.” How do your feelings affect your prayers, and what does his story teach you about them?
  • How can your church care better for people who struggle with deep sadness, without telling them that their faith is weak?

Read more on Ochorus

  • David Brainerd, The Life and Diary of David Brainerd, especially “From President Edwards’ Preface”
  • David Brainerd, The Life and Diary of David Brainerd (For Teens), especially “Praying in the Woods”
Scripture Galatians 4:19

You finished Praying in the Snow

Previous Next