Morning Comes
The Black Water

Chapter 1 · 18 min read · 23 min listen

The Black Water

The fishing village of Skerrow lay at the bottom of the cliffs where the Harrowgate Highlands fell into the sea, and it was the last place in Gloamhaven.

That is what the people of Skerrow said, anyway, and they said it with a sort of gloomy pride. The last place. Beyond it there was nothing: only the headland, a long black arm of rock reaching out into the water; and beyond the headland, the Sunless Sea. You could see where it began. The ordinary sea in the bay at Skerrow was grey, the way all the sea in Gloamhaven was grey — grey-green in the shallows, grey-blue further out, with grey waves and white foam and grey gulls crying over it. But past the end of the headland, as if somebody had drawn a line across the water with a ruler, it went black. Flat black, and still, like ink in a dish. And nothing came back from it: no gull, no wave, no light.

The fisherfolk of Skerrow fished with their backs to it. They had done so for three hundred years.

“Daft,” said Skipper Mairi Dunlop. “Daft as a brush. The lot of us.”

She was standing on the harbour wall in the grey dawn with her great red hands on her hips, looking out at the black line beyond the headland as if it owed her money. She was about sixty, and broad as a barrel, and her face was the colour and texture of an old leather boot that has been left out in the weather for a long time and enjoyed it. She wore three jerseys, one on top of another, and a pair of enormous sea-boots that had belonged to her grandmother, which she swore by.

“Three hundred years,” she said, “we’ve sat in this harbour and looked the other way. Never once put out a line past the Skerry. Never once asked what’s out there. Just turned our backs on it, like a lot of hens that think if they can’t see the fox it can’t see them.” She spat into the water. “Well, I’m sixty-one and I’ve had the Flame in me since the siege, and I’m done with it. Somebody has to be daft first.”

“Daft first,” said Wren.

“Then everybody,” said Mairi Dunlop, and grinned, so that her whole leather face cracked into creases. “That’s how it goes, hen. Somebody’s got to be daft first. And then everybody else sees it’s not so bad, and they’re daft too.” She clapped Wren on the shoulder so hard that Wren nearly went off the wall. “Come and see my boat.”

Her boat was called the Brave Gannet, and it was the oldest boat on the coast.

It was not very big. It was a broad, deep, heavy fishing-boat with one mast and a brown sail — a real brown, Mira said, staring at it, the colour of a fox’s back; the Flame had been in Skerrow a fortnight — and a little cuddy at the front where you could get out of the rain if you did not mind sharing it with the nets. It had been painted once, a long time ago, and the paint had mostly come off. It smelt overpoweringly of fish. It had been built by Mairi’s great-grandfather, she said, out of oak from a wood that wasn’t there any more, and it had been patched so often that there was probably not one plank left of the first boat; but it was still the Gannet, and it still floated.

“Most days,” said Mairi.

Tobin looked at the boat for a long time, and then at the black line beyond the headland, and then at the boat again, and opened his mouth.

“Don’t,” said Mira.

“I was only going to ask—“

“I know what you were going to ask. Don’t.”

Tobin shut his mouth.

There were to be nine of them on the Gannet.

Mairi Dunlop, the skipper. Her two grandsons, Callum and Rab, great silent red-headed lads of sixteen and seventeen who could haul a net single-handed and were terrified of their grandmother. Wren, with the lamp. Tobin, with Ash’s pole and his mother’s compass and a bag of tools and three notebooks, one of them entirely full of sums about the speed of boats. Mira, with the Chronicle. Aren. And Cinder.

And Sister Hale.

Nobody had wanted Sister Hale to come. That is to say, everybody had wanted her to come very much, and nobody had thought she should. She was old, and lame, and her arm was only just out of its sling. The Sunless Sea was four days away, Aren said, if there was wind; and nobody knew if there was ever wind. And at the end of it was the Queen’s own tower.

“So you should stay in Harrowgate,” Wren had said. “And look after everybody. Like you did on the Hill. You’re good at it.”

“I am good at it,” Sister Hale had agreed. “Very good. Best there is.” She had been sitting on the bench outside the Black Bull, with her crutch across her knees, and she had looked up at Wren with her one bright eye. “And I’ve waited seventy years, duck. Seventy years in barns and cellars and ditches, singing his songs with my back to the wall and the Guild going by on the road. I waited on the Hill. I waited for Midsummer. I’ve waited my whole life for him to come back, and I’ll go on waiting till he does.” She had patted Wren’s knee. “But I’m not waiting here. Not while you lot go off to the end of the world without me. I’m coming.”

“But—“

“I’m coming, duck.”

So she was coming.

Half of Harrowgate came down the cliff path to Skerrow to see them off, and most of Skerrow, and all of the Remnant who had come with Sister Hale’s carts, and Bracken, who was going back to Emberwick that same day to take the Beacon back from Mott — “before he gives the whole Ring away, lass, and the wall with it” — and the Heskeths, and the children of Stallbridge. They stood all along the harbour wall in the grey morning, and on the rocks, and in the doorways of the tarred fish-huts, holding up their lamps and candles and bare glowing hands. Even in the daylight, even under the pale sun, the whole harbour of Skerrow shone gold with them.

Nettle was not there.

Wren looked for her everywhere. Nettle had been told — very firmly, by everybody, again — that she was not coming on the boat. Not this time. Not to the Spire. She was going back to Emberwick with Mrs Fenn’s eldest and Bracken, in the bakery cart, and that was final. And Nettle had said nothing at all, which was not like Nettle; and that morning, when everybody else came down the cliff path, she was nowhere to be seen.

“She’s sulking,” said Mrs Fenn’s eldest. “She’ll be in the cart. Sulking. She’ll get over it.”

But Wren did not like it.

They said their goodbyes. It took a long time.

Bracken shook Wren’s hand, the way he had on the morning after the Ring was lit, a year ago; and then, rather awkwardly, hugged her, helmet and all. “You come back,” he said. “You hear me, lass? You come back. And bring that Warden of mine.” He looked over her head at Tobin. “Bring him, I said.”

“I will,” said Tobin.

Will Hesketh did not say anything. He put his big warm hands on Wren’s shoulders for a moment, and that was all, and it was enough.

Sister Hale was helped down into the Gannet by four people, and sat down in the stern on a coil of rope, and arranged her crutch, and announced that she felt very well and was looking forward to it enormously; and then the boat moved, a little, on its mooring, and she went the colour of an old cabbage and said nothing else for some time.

And Aren stood on the harbour wall at the very end, by himself, looking out at the black line.

He had been quiet all morning. Quieter than usual. Wren had seen people on the wall look at him — the Skerrow men, especially, the ones who had been Knights, and come home after the siege, and had their names given back. They did not look at him with fear, any more. They looked at him the way you look at somebody who is about to go back into a burning house.

“It’s all right,” said Wren. She had come up beside him without meaning to. “You don’t have to come. Nobody’d think—“

“I do have to,” said Aren.

He did not look at her. He was looking out past the Skerry at the flat black water, where the light did not come back.

“I took them there,” he said. “Your mother and father. Harrowgate’s father. Thousands of them. I took them all. Every one.” He was rubbing his palm; then he noticed, and stopped, and opened his hand and looked at the gold line shining across it. “I’m the only one who knows the way in. I’m the only one who knows the stairs.” He closed his hand again. “I have to go back, Wren. I have to be the one who goes back for them.”

Wren did not say anything. After a moment, she nodded.

They cast off at the turn of the tide.

Callum and Rab rowed them out across the bay, with long sweeps, the Gannet wallowing and creaking, until they were clear of the harbour; and then Mairi Dunlop put up the brown sail, and the grey morning wind off the land filled it, and the Gannet leaned over and began to move.

Everybody on the harbour wall cheered.

Wren stood in the bow with Cinder on her shoulder and watched them get smaller — the lights on the wall, and the waving arms, and the tarred huts, and the cliffs going up behind to the edge of the Highlands, where the heather was. She had never been on a boat before, except the Ferryman’s, a year ago, in the mist on the Gloam River. It was different from walking. The ground moved. Everything moved. It was like riding a very large, very slow, very wet animal that had its own ideas about where it was going.

And then, from somewhere at the back of the boat, a voice said, quite clearly, “Thtop thquashing me.”

Everybody turned round.

In the stern of the Gannet, beside Sister Hale, was a pile of lobster pots: big domed wicker baskets, stacked up and lashed together, that Mairi had not had time to unload. And the top one was moving.

It wobbled. It rocked. It said “Ow.” And then its lid came off, and out of it, like a jack-in-the-box, sticky with fish-scales and bits of weed and smelling indescribably of old lobster, came Nettle.

There was a long silence on the Brave Gannet.

“NETTLE,” said Wren.

“I’m coming,” said Nettle. She climbed out of the lobster pot with enormous dignity, and stood up in the stern, and folded her arms. There was a small crab hanging on to one of her plaits. “I’m coming, Wren. You can’t thtop me. I’m coming to get your mam and dad.”

“You are not—“

“I am. Becauthe you alwayth go. You alwayth go away and leave me and I wait and wait and you never even thend a letter and I’m not doing it any more.” Her chin was out and her face was red and her eyes were full. “I’ve got the Flame. Same ath you. Same ath anybody. He gave it me. Tho I can come.”

“Nettle—“

“I lit an oven.”

Wren looked at her. At her small furious floury face, with the crab on its plait, and the tears running down it; and her two new front teeth; and the little gold glow coming faintly off her clenched hands. And Wren thought — she could not help it — of herself. Of herself at eight, in Mott’s yard, being told for the hundredth time that she was too small, and too poor, and too nobody, for anything at all; and setting her chin exactly like that.

“Turn the boat round,” she said to Mairi Dunlop.

Nettle burst into tears.

They put her ashore at the end of the harbour wall.

It was the hardest thing Wren had done since the Moffats’ weaving-room. Mairi turned the Gannet — grumbling, but quite gently — and Callum and Rab rowed her back in, against the tide, to the steps at the very end of the wall where the crowd was still standing, staring. And Wren lifted Nettle up out of the boat, lobster-smell and crab and all, and handed her up to Bracken, who took her under one arm like a parcel.

Nettle did not fight. She did not kick, or scream, or shout, which Wren had been ready for. She only cried, quietly, the way she used to cry when she was cold in the garret, with her face turned away.

Wren climbed up two steps of the harbour wall, so that her face was level with Nettle’s.

“Nettle,” she said. “Listen. Listen to me.” She took the small sticky face in both hands and turned it round. “I’m not going away and leaving you. Not this time. Not like before. I’m going to get them. My mam and dad. And Tobin’s da. And all of them. And then I’m going to bring them home. To Soot Lane. To the bakery.” She swallowed. “And I need somebody there. When I get back. Somebody to keep the Flame in the lane. Somebody to light every door, so it’s lit when I come. So I know where home is.” She held on. “Will you do it? For me? Will you keep it lit?”

Nettle looked at her for a long time, with her lip shaking.

“Promith?” she said. “Promith you’ll come back?”

“I promise.”

“You alwayth thay that.”

“And I always do,” said Wren.

Nettle considered this. She was still crying. But she reached up, slowly, and took the crab off her own plait, and gave it to Wren, very solemnly, as if it were something precious.

“Keep it,” she said. “For luck.”

Wren put the crab in her pocket. It nipped her, all the way out of the harbour.

And so they went out past the Skerry.

The headland went by on the left, long and black and wet, with the grey sea breaking white against the foot of it; and the end of it came up, a jagged rock with a single stunted tree on top, bent sideways by the wind. And beyond it, the line.

Wren stood in the bow and watched it come.

It came closer slowly, the way the shore of a river comes closer when you are rowing across. Grey water — grey water — the little grey waves slapping at the Gannet’s bow, the gulls crying overhead, the wind cold and salt in her face. And then, right in front of them, as if somebody had drawn it with a ruler: black.

The Gannet’s bow went over the line.

And the gulls stopped.

That was the first thing. Wren had not even noticed the gulls until they stopped; they had been crying over the boat all morning, wheeling and calling, the way they always did at sea. And the moment the bow crossed into the black water, every gull turned in the air at once, and went back. Back to the Skerry, back to the grey water, back to the land. Not one of them followed. And in the silence after them Wren could hear, very clearly, the creak of the Gannet’s mast, and the slap of the brown sail, and Sister Hale being sick over the side.

The second thing was the water.

It was not like water. It was flat, and black, and thick-looking, like oil, or ink. It did not have waves — not real ones — only a long, slow, heavy heave, as if something very big were breathing underneath it. It did not make a sound against the hull. And when Wren leaned over the bow and looked down into it, nothing came back. No reflection. Not of the Gannet, or the brown sail, or the grey sky, or her own face. She took the lamp out of her coat and held it out over the side, so that its gold light fell on the black water, the way it would fall on a puddle in Soot Lane, and there should have been a little gold lamp shining back up at her from the sea—

There was nothing.

The light went into the black water and did not come back. As if the sea were drinking it.

The third thing was the cold. It came up through the planks of the boat, from below, into the soles of their feet. It was not like the cold of the Hollows, which came at you; it was a slower cold, heavier, patient, the cold of a cellar that has been shut for a long time.

Wren put the lamp away inside her coat again, against her ribs, where it was warm.

“Well,” said Mairi Dunlop, at the tiller, into the silence. Her leather face was set, and her great red hands were very steady. “That’s the gulls gone, then.”

And she set the Gannet’s course east, by Tobin’s compass, out into the Sunless Sea.

They sailed all day.

The wind off the land held, a little, cold and thin, and filled the brown sail, and the Gannet went on east over the black water with no sound at all except her own creaking. The land went down behind them, slowly — the Skerry, and the cliffs, and the dark line of the Highlands — until it was only a grey smudge, and then not even that. The sky was grey. The sea was black. There was nothing else.

Tobin sat in the waist of the boat with the compass open on his knee and watched the needle. It pointed east, and stayed east, and was warm.

Mira sat beside Sister Hale, holding her hand and the Chronicle at the same time.

Aren stood in the bow, alone, looking forward into the grey, and did not move for hours.

And Sister Hale — once she had finished being sick, which took most of the morning — sat up in the stern on her coil of rope, very pale, and wiped her mouth on her shawl, and began, in a thin cracked voice that got slowly stronger, to sing.

It was the Psalm. Though I walk through the gloaming. She sang it out over the black water, the way she had sung it in barns, and the black water did not give one note of it back. It went out from the boat and did not echo. It was like singing into a pillow. And she sang it anyway, all the way through, every verse, including the one with the goat in it.

And one by one, they all joined in.

The dark came down at the end of the day, the way it always did in Gloamhaven, quickly, like a lid.

But it was different out here. On the land, even on the blackest night, there was always something: a Ring-lamp on a wall far off, or a glimmer of moon behind cloud, or the faint grey of the sky over the edge of the world. Out on the Sunless Sea, when the dark came down, it came down all the way. The Gannet was a little island of gold in it — the lamp in Wren’s coat, and Mira’s candle, and the glow of everybody’s hands — and outside that little circle of gold, in every direction, there was nothing. Not black water. Not sky. Nothing at all.

Wren lay in the bottom of the boat on a heap of nets, with Cinder against her and Nettle’s crab asleep in her pocket, and looked up.

Tobin was lying beside her, looking up too. After a while she heard him draw in his breath.

“Wren,” he said, very quietly.

“What?”

“There aren’t any stars.”

She looked.

He was right. Even on the cloudiest nights in Gloamhaven, even through the grey, there was always a star somewhere — one, at least, very faint, low down, the kind you only see if you don’t look straight at it. Wren had found them from the roofs of Soot Lane since she was six; it was the only thing up there worth looking at.

There were none. Not one. The sky over the Sunless Sea was as black and flat and empty as the water under it, from one side to the other; and the little boat with its little gold light lay between the two of them, in the middle of nothing, going east.

Tobin felt for the compass in the dark, and opened it, and put his finger on the glass.

“Still warm,” he said.

“Good,” said Wren.

And after a long time, with the lamp against her ribs and the fox against her stomach, she slept.

Next