Jesus, Teacher of Prayer
Not My Will but Yours

Chapter 19 · 8 min read · 10 min listen

Not My Will but Yours

“He went a little farther, threw Himself face down on the ground, and prayed, ‘My Father, if there is any way, let this cup pass by Me. But not what I want; what You want.’” (Matthew 26:39)

The name Gethsemane means “oil press.” It was a garden of olive trees on the slope of the Mount of Olives, just across the valley from Jerusalem. In the press, olives were crushed under heavy stones until the oil ran out. On the night Jesus was betrayed, He went there to pray, and He Himself was crushed.

It was late. The Passover moon was full. Jesus left most of His disciples near the entrance: “Stay seated here while I go on over there and pray” (Matthew 26:36). He took Peter, James and John a little farther, the same three who had seen His glory on the mountain of transfiguration. Now they would see His agony.

“He began to be filled with grief and anguish. Then He said to them, ‘My soul is weighed down with grief, even to death. Stay here and keep awake with Me.’” (Matthew 26:37-38)

Then He went a little farther still, alone, and fell with His face to the ground.

The cup

What was the “cup” Jesus asked His Father to take away? In the Old Testament, the cup is often a picture of God’s judgment against sin. Jesus was about to bear that judgment for us. It was not only the physical pain of the cross, terrible as it was. It was the weight of the sin of the world, and the darkness of being separated from His Father. “It was for our rebellions that He was pierced through, for our guilt that He was crushed” (Isaiah 53:5).

Luke, who was a doctor, adds details the others leave out:

“Then an angel from heaven appeared to Him and gave Him strength. In His anguish He prayed all the more intensely, and His sweat became like thick drops of blood dripping down onto the ground.” (Luke 22:43-44)

(Some of the oldest copies of Luke’s Gospel do not include these two verses, but they have been read in the church since very early times.)

The writer of Hebrews remembered this night too: “He offered up prayers and pleas, crying aloud and weeping, to the one who was able to save Him out of death, and He was heard for His godly fear” (Hebrews 5:7).

An honest prayer

Look at the first half of Jesus’ prayer: “My Father, if there is any way, let this cup pass by Me.”

Jesus was completely honest with His Father. He did not pretend to be calm. He did not hide what He wanted. He said, in effect, “Father, I do not want this. If there is any other way, please take it away.” Here is the Son of God, sinless and perfect, telling the Father plainly what His heart desired.

That gives us permission to be honest too. Prayer is not the place for pretending. If you are afraid, tell God. If you want something desperately, tell Him. If the path ahead looks unbearable, tell Him that too. Jesus did.

A surrendered prayer

But then comes the second half: “But not what I want; what You want.”

Jesus prayed this prayer three times that night (Matthew 26:44). The second time, His words had already moved: “My Father, if there is no way for this to pass unless I drink it, then let Your will be done” (Matthew 26:42). In those hours of prayer, Jesus brought His human will into perfect agreement with His Father’s will.

This is the heart of Gethsemane. It is not a prayer of giving up. It is a prayer of giving over. Jesus did not stop wanting the cup to pass because He had lost hope, but because He trusted His Father more than His own desires. And Hebrews says He “was heard.” The cup was not taken away, but He was heard. He was given strength to drink it, and through His suffering He won salvation for the world.

E. M. Bounds wrote movingly about this prayer. He knew that every believer will have a Gethsemane of their own:

“‘Not my will, but thine, be done,’ our broken hearts shall say.”

E. M. Bounds, The Reality of Prayer

But Bounds also gave a warning. Some people use “Your will be done” as an excuse not to pray with faith and effort, as if it meant “whatever happens, happens”:

“We are ever ready to excuse our lack of earnest and toilsome praying, by a fancied and delusive view of submission.”

E. M. Bounds, The Reality of Prayer

Jesus’ surrender in Gethsemane was not lazy or passive. He prayed so intensely that His sweat fell like drops of blood. True surrender comes at the end of honest, wrestling prayer, not instead of it.

Sleeping friends

While Jesus prayed, His closest friends fell asleep. Three times He came back and found them sleeping. “So none of you could stay awake with Me for even one hour?” He said to Peter. “Stay alert and pray that you will not come into testing. The spirit is eager, but human nature is weak” (Matthew 26:40-41).

There is sadness in those words, but also great kindness. Jesus understood their weakness. And His warning came true: within hours they had all run away. Jesus, who had prayed, stood firm. They, who had slept, fell.

Then, at the end, Jesus rose from the ground, calm and ready: “Get up; let us be going. Here comes the man who is betraying Me” (Matthew 26:46). He had gone into the garden crushed with sorrow. He came out with the strength to face the cross. Prayer had not changed the path, but it had prepared Him to walk it.

Three key insights

  1. We can be honest with God about what we want. Jesus told His Father plainly that He wanted the cup to pass. Prayer is not the place for pretending; we can pour out our true desires to Him.
  2. Surrender is giving over, not giving up. “Not what I want; what You want” is not the prayer of someone who has lost hope. It is the prayer of someone who trusts the Father more than their own desires.
  3. Prayer prepares us for what we must face. The cup did not pass, but Jesus rose from prayer strengthened and ready. Sometimes God answers not by changing the road, but by giving us strength to walk it.

For us today

Everyone who follows Jesus will come to a Gethsemane. It may be a diagnosis, a death, a betrayal, a persecution, a call from God to do something very hard. It may be a moment when we must choose between our own will and God’s. In that place, we can pray as Jesus prayed.

First, tell God honestly what you want. Do not be ashamed of your fear or your tears. Jesus wept and cried aloud. Then, as you keep praying, ask Him for the grace to say, “Not what I want; what You want.” That may take time. Jesus prayed three times. It may take a whole night, or many nights. But it is the way to peace and to strength.

And if you have friends who are in their Gethsemane, do not fall asleep on them. Stay awake with them. Pray with them. It is one of the greatest gifts we can give.

Try this

This week, learn to pray the Gethsemane prayer.

  • Name your cup. Think of the hardest thing you are facing, or the thing you fear most. Write it down.
  • Pray honestly. Tell God exactly what you want about it, holding nothing back. “Father, if there is any way, let this pass.”
  • Pray surrender. Then pray, “But not what I want; what You want.” If you cannot mean it yet, ask God to help you mean it. Pray it again tomorrow.
  • Watch with someone. Think of one person who is going through a hard time. Stay alert for them this week: call them, visit them, or pray with them.

A closing prayer

Father, Your Son knelt in the garden and prayed with tears. Thank You that I can be honest with You about what I want and what I fear. Here is my cup: You know it. If there is any way, take it from me. But not what I want; what You want. Give me the trust to say that and mean it. And when the path does not change, give me the strength to walk it, as You gave strength to Jesus. Keep me awake and praying, for myself and for those who need me. In His name. Amen.

Questions for reflection

  • What is your “cup” right now, the thing you most wish God would take away?
  • What is the difference between giving up and giving over? How did Jesus show it?
  • Bounds warns that “Your will be done” can become an excuse not to pray earnestly. Have you ever used it that way?

Read more on Ochorus

  • E. M. Bounds, The Reality of Prayer, especially “The Gethsemane Prayer”
  • Dwight L. Moody, Prevailing Prayer, especially “Submission”
Previous Next