Jesus, Teacher of Prayer
“God, Have Mercy on Me, a Sinner”

Chapter 10 · 8 min read · 10 min listen

“God, Have Mercy on Me, a Sinner”

“The tax collector, though, kept back at a distance and would not even lift his eyes toward heaven. Instead he struck his chest again and again and said, ‘God, be merciful to me, the sinner!’” (Luke 18:13)

Luke tells us exactly whom this story was for:

“There were some who relied on themselves, sure that they were righteous, and who looked down on all others. Jesus told them this parable.” (Luke 18:9)

Then Jesus painted a scene that everyone listening could see in their minds. It is the hour of prayer at the temple in Jerusalem. The great courts are filling with worshipers. The smoke of the sacrifice rises from the altar. And two men come up the steps to pray.

“Two men went up to the temple to pray. One was a Pharisee, and the other was a tax collector.” (Luke 18:10)

To Jesus’ first listeners, the story seemed to be over before it began. Everyone knew who the good man was and who the bad man was.

The Pharisees were the most respected religious people of their day. They studied the Scriptures, kept the law carefully, prayed at the set hours and gave generously. Ordinary people looked up to them.

Tax collectors were among the most hated people in the land. They worked for the Roman occupiers, collecting money from their own people, and many of them took far more than they should and kept the difference. They were seen as traitors and thieves. Respectable people would not eat with them.

So the listeners waited to hear how the good man would be praised and the bad man condemned.

Two prayers

The Pharisee stood up and prayed. Luke’s wording is striking: he “prayed this prayer about himself.”

“God, I thank You that I am not like the rest of humanity, who are swindlers, crooks and adulterers, or even like this tax collector. Twice every week I fast, and I give a tenth of everything I take in.” (Luke 18:11-12)

Everything he said may have been true. He probably did fast twice a week and give a tenth of his income. Those are good things. But listen to his prayer. He begins with “God,” and then he never mentions God again. He asks for nothing. He confesses nothing. His prayer is a list of his own achievements, and a comparison with people he thinks are worse than him. He even glances across the court at the tax collector and uses him as an example.

Then Jesus turns our eyes to the other man. He “kept back at a distance.” He would not even lift his eyes toward heaven. He struck his chest again and again, the way people did in deep grief. And he prayed just seven words in our English Bible:

“God, be merciful to me, the sinner!”

He did not compare himself with anyone. He did not list his good deeds. He did not make excuses. He called himself not a sinner, but the sinner, as if there were no one worse. He threw himself completely on the mercy of God.

The word he used for “be merciful” is connected in the Bible with the sacrifice that covered sin. As the smoke of the offering rose from the altar, he was asking God to accept that sacrifice for him. He had nothing to offer God but his need.

The shock

Then Jesus gave His verdict, and it turned the whole world upside down:

“I tell you, it was this man, not the other, who went home put right with God. For everyone who lifts themselves up will be brought low, and the one who takes the low place will be lifted up.” (Luke 18:14)

The religious man went home exactly as he came. The sinner went home forgiven.

Dwight L. Moody, the American evangelist who preached to millions in the 1800s, loved this short prayer. He noticed how quickly it was answered:

“How short the publican’s prayer was: ‘God be merciful to me a sinner!’ The Syrophenician woman’s was shorter still: ‘Lord help me!’ She went right to the mark, and she got what she wanted.”

Dwight L. Moody, Prevailing Prayer

(“Publican” is the old English word for a tax collector.)

Humility, the doorway of prayer

The Bible says the same thing in many places. God is high and holy, and yet, as Isaiah heard Him say, “I am also with the one who is crushed and low in spirit” (Isaiah 57:15). David, after his own great sin, prayed, “A heart that is broken and crushed, God, You will never reject” (Psalm 51:17). James wrote, “God sets Himself against the proud, but to the humble He gives grace” (James 4:6).

Andrew Murray wrote a whole book on humility, and he saw this parable as part of a pattern that runs through all of Jesus’ teaching:

“The lowliest is the nearest to God.”

Andrew Murray, Humility

And:

“Humiliation is the only ladder to honour in God’s kingdom.”

Andrew Murray, Humility

This is not about pretending to be worse than we are, or hating ourselves. It is simply about telling the truth. “Everyone has sinned, and all come short of God’s glory” (Romans 3:23). The Pharisee did not see that truth about himself. The tax collector did. And the truth set him free.

The tax collector’s prayer became one of the best-loved prayers in the history of the church. A blind beggar on the road to Jericho cried something very like it to Jesus, “Jesus, Son of David, have mercy on me!” (Luke 18:38), only a few verses later in Luke’s Gospel. In Volume 4 we will meet Christians in the deserts of Egypt and the monasteries of the East who joined these cries into a short prayer they prayed thousands of times: “Lord Jesus Christ, Son of God, have mercy on me, a sinner.” Christians all over the world still pray it today.

Three key insights

  1. Humility is the doorway of prayer. God hears the prayer that comes from an honest and humble heart. We do not need fine words or a good record. We need to come as we are and ask for mercy.
  2. Comparing ourselves with others poisons prayer. The Pharisee’s prayer was ruined by his eye on the tax collector. When we pray, our eyes belong on God, not on the people we think are worse than us.
  3. God answers the cry for mercy at once. The tax collector went home put right with God that same day. No one is too sinful to pray this prayer, and no one who prays it sincerely is turned away.

For us today

This parable is a warning especially for religious people, and that includes most of us who read books like this one. It is possible to pray, fast, give, go to church and read the Bible, and still be the Pharisee. The danger is not in the good things we do. It is in trusting them, and in looking down on others.

The Pharisee’s prayer can take many forms. “Thank God I’m not like those people.” Those people might be another church, another tribe, another nation, another political party, or the neighbor whose life is a mess. Whenever we find ourselves thinking that way, the tax collector’s prayer is the cure. We stop looking sideways and look up.

And if you are the tax collector, if you feel too sinful, too broken or too far gone to pray, this parable is for you. You do not need to clean yourself up first. You do not need to find the right words. Seven words are enough. Jesus told this story so that you would know that God is waiting to hear them.

Try this

This week, let the tax collector teach you to pray.

  • Pray his prayer each morning. Say slowly, “God, be merciful to me, the sinner.” Then be quiet, and receive His mercy with thanks.
  • Pray it through the day. Moody noticed how short the best prayers are. Whenever you remember during the day, pray it again silently: while you work, walk or wait.
  • Check your comparisons. Ask the Holy Spirit to show you anyone you look down on. Then pray for that person, asking God to bless them.
  • Confess one thing honestly. Bring to God one sin you have been excusing, and ask for His forgiveness without making excuses.

A closing prayer

God, be merciful to me, the sinner. I come to You with nothing to offer but my need. Forgive me for the times I have trusted in my own goodness and looked down on others. Forgive me for comparing myself with anyone but Jesus. Thank You that You do not turn away a broken and humble heart. Thank You that Jesus Himself is the sacrifice for my sin. Send me home today put right with You. Amen.

Questions for reflection

  • In what ways are you tempted to pray like the Pharisee?
  • Who are the people you are most tempted to look down on? What would it mean to pray for them?
  • Why do you think such a short prayer was enough for the tax collector? What does that teach you about prayer?

Read more on Ochorus

  • Andrew Murray, Humility, especially “Humility in the Teaching of Jesus”
  • Dwight L. Moody, Prevailing Prayer, especially “Confession”
  • John Bunyan, The Jerusalem Sinner Saved
Previous Next