Chapter 11 · 9 min read · 11 min listen
A Struggle to the Last Breath
“Our fight is not with flesh and blood. It is with the rulers, with the authorities, with the world rulers of this darkness, with the spiritual forces of evil in the heavenly places.” (Ephesians 6:12)
West of the green land of the Nile Delta, the ground turns to sand and stone. In the 300s this empty country was called Scetis. There was no town there and very little water. Yet by the time Antony died, many Christians were living in it. Each had a small cell of mud brick or stone. They wove baskets and ropes from palm leaves and sold them to buy bread. On Saturdays and Sundays they gathered to worship together, and then went back to their cells to pray.
One of these monks was a man named Agathon. In time other monks called him “Abba,” which means “father,” and came to him for advice. Once, in town to sell his baskets, he found a sick traveler lying alone in the street. Agathon rented a room and cared for him for four months, paying with his own work, until the man was well.
One day some of the brothers came to Agathon with a question. Of all the good things a Christian can do, they asked, which one takes the greatest effort? Fasting? Night watches? Giving everything away?
Agathon’s answer surprised them. He told them that, as far as he could see, no labor is as great as prayer to God. When a person wants to pray, he said, the enemies of the soul try to stop him, because they know that if they can turn him away from prayer, they can stop his journey to God. With every other good work, if a person keeps at it, there comes a time of rest. But prayer is not like that. Prayer, he told them, is a battle that lasts to our last breath.
The story is told that as he lay dying, he stayed three days with his eyes open, as if looking at something. The brothers asked where he was. He told them he was standing before the judgment seat of God. He would not put his confidence in all his years of hard work, because, he said, the judgment of God is not like the judgment of people. And the brothers who were there said that he died with joy, like a man greeting his dearest friends.
A desert full of praying people
These stories come from the Sayings of the Desert Fathers. For many years the monks passed them on by word of mouth, until they were written down in the late 400s and 500s, in Greek and soon in Latin, Syriac and Coptic. (A word of care: many sayings found online under the name of a desert father are not in these collections.)
After Antony, the desert filled with people. In Egypt there were great centers of monks at Nitria, Kellia (“the Cells”) and Scetis. In the south, a former soldier named Pachomius gathered large numbers of monks into communities that lived and prayed together under a rule. In Palestine, a monk named Hilarion settled in the dry country near Gaza, and Jerome wrote his life. In Syria, a hermit named Simeon lived for many years on top of a stone pillar east of Antioch, and crowds came to hear him. Bishop Theodoret, who visited him, wrote about him while he was still alive.
And there were women. The collections call them “Amma,” which means “mother,” and they were honored as teachers. Amma Syncletica of Alexandria gave away her wealth to live a hidden life of prayer, and other women gathered around her. Amma Sarah, the sayings tell us, lived for sixty years beside a river. Amma Theodora discussed the Scriptures with the bishop of Alexandria, and many monks sought her advice.
How they prayed
The desert mothers and fathers believed Paul’s words about this fight. They spoke often of demons, and they meant real spiritual enemies, as Paul did. But most of the battles in their sayings are very ordinary: anger, pride, impure thoughts, laziness, discouragement, the wish to give up. They went to the desert to face these things honestly, before God.
So their first lesson was: expect prayer to be hard. Amma Theodora told of a monk who felt cold and feverish and had headaches every time he began to pray. At last he told himself that since he was ill and might soon die, he had better get up and pray before he died. So he forced himself to pray, and when he finished, the fever had gone. The things that keep us from prayer are often weaker than they seem.
Their second lesson was: ask for strength, not only for escape. Amma Sarah, the sayings say, struggled for many years against impure desires. But she never prayed that the battle would stop. She prayed only that God would give her strength.
Their third lesson was: keep prayer simple. When the brothers asked Abba Macarius how they should pray, he told them there was no need for long speeches. It is enough, he said, to stretch out your hands and ask the Lord to have mercy, as He wills and as He knows. And if the struggle grows fierce, simply cry to Him for help.
Their fourth lesson was: keep going. Abba Arsenius, who had once lived at the emperor’s court, would stand on Saturday evening with the setting sun behind him and his hands raised toward heaven, and pray until the rising sun shone on his face. Few could do that, but all of them believed in returning to God again and again. Abba Poemen said that water is soft and stone is hard, yet water dripping on a stone wears it away. In the same way, he said, our hearts are hard, but “if it heareth continually the Word of God, the heart will be opened.”
Many centuries later, E. M. Bounds wrote words the desert would have understood. By “closet” he meant a private room for prayer:
“The closet is not an asylum for the indolent and worthless Christian. It is not a nursery where none but babes belong. It is the battlefield of the Church; its citadel; the scene of heroic and unearthly conflicts.”
E. M. Bounds, Purpose in Prayer
Three key insights
- If prayer feels like a struggle, you are not failing; you are fighting. Agathon, who spent his life in prayer, called it the hardest work of all. The tiredness and wandering thoughts that come when we kneel are part of the battle Paul describes.
- God’s grace can be enough for a struggle He does not take away. Amma Sarah did not pray for an easy life. She asked only for strength, and she kept standing. God may not remove every struggle, but His grace is enough for it (2 Corinthians 12:9).
- Coming back to God again and again slowly softens a hard heart. Abba Poemen’s water does its work drop by drop. A few humble words, such as “Lord, have mercy” or “Lord, help!”, prayed day after day, keep turning us back to God, and He does the rest.
For us today
Most of us will never live in a desert. We live in crowded cities, in villages, in small rooms full of family. But the desert mothers and fathers did not think the desert was magic. Amma Syncletica warned that a person can live on a mountain and still have a mind full of the noise of the town, while another can live in a crowd and keep a quiet heart before God.
In chapter 6 we saw that Paul’s teaching on the armor of God ends with prayer, and that he asks us to keep watch, never giving up (Ephesians 6:18). Keep watch. Never give up. That is the whole teaching of the desert.
This is a word for believers who suffer for their faith today. Where Christians are watched, threatened or put in prison, the real fight is not with the officials or the neighbors who hate them, who are only flesh and blood. It is a spiritual fight, and it is fought on our knees, often with very few words. Peter wrote to suffering Christians: “Stand up to him and hold firm in your faith. You know that your brothers and sisters all over the world are enduring these same sufferings” (1 Peter 5:9). You are not alone in the fight.
And if you find prayer hard, take comfort: so did Agathon, to his last breath. Do not wait until prayer feels easy. Pray now, as you are.
Try this
This week, practice the simple prayers of the desert.
- Begin with open hands. When you sit down to pray, open your hands in front of you and use Macarius’s words as your own: Lord, as You will, and as You know, have mercy.
- Use a short cry in the battle. When anger, fear or temptation rises during the day, pray at once, “Lord, help!”
- Ask for strength. Name one struggle that God has not yet taken away. Pray as Amma Sarah did, and ask God for strength to stand.
- Notice your excuses. When you feel too tired or too busy to pray, pray for just two minutes anyway, as Theodora’s monk did. Notice what happens.
A closing prayer
Lord Jesus Christ, You fought the great battle for us on the cross, and You won. Teach me to stand in Your strength and not my own. When prayer is hard, keep me from giving up. When my thoughts wander, bring them back to You. When temptation comes, I do not ask only for an easy road; give me strength for the fight. Thank You for the mothers and fathers of the desert who prayed to their last breath. Make me faithful like them, until I see Your face with joy. Lord, as You will, and as You know, have mercy on me. Amen.
Questions for reflection
- What usually happens when you try to pray? What gets in the way?
- Why do you think Agathon called prayer the hardest of all good works?
- Is there a struggle in your life where you could pray for strength instead of only for escape?
Read more on Ochorus
- Athanasius, The Life of Antony, especially “His address to monks, rendered from Coptic, exhorting them to perseverance, and encouraging them against the wiles of Satan”
- E. M. Bounds, Purpose in Prayer, especially “Prayer Is a Trade to Be Learned”
- Jerome, The Letters of St. Jerome, especially “Letter XXII: To Eustochium”