Chapter 9 · 8 min read · 11 min listen
Peter in Prison, the Church on Its Knees
“So Peter was under guard in the prison, but the church was praying to God for him without letup.” (Acts 12:5)
The story begins with a grave.
King Herod Agrippa, a grandson of the Herod who tried to kill the baby Jesus, turned violently against the church. Luke tells it in one short, terrible sentence:
“He executed James, John’s brother, with the sword.” (Acts 12:2)
James was one of the first fishermen Jesus called. He had been with Jesus on the mountain when His face shone, and in the garden when He prayed in agony. He was one of the inner three. Now he was dead, the first of the twelve apostles to die for his Lord. Luke gives him only one verse.
The killing pleased many people, so Herod went further. He arrested Peter. It was the week of the Feast of Unleavened Bread, the festival that came with the Passover, and Jerusalem was full of pilgrims. Herod planned to bring Peter out before the crowds when the feast was over. Everyone could guess what that meant. James’s death had shown it.
Herod made sure that Peter could not escape. He handed Peter over to four squads of four soldiers, sixteen men taking turns. At night Peter slept chained between two of them, with more guards at the door.
And the church? The church had no soldiers and no influence at the palace. It had just buried one of its leaders. It did the one thing it could do. “The church was praying to God for him without letup.” Day after day, and through the nights, the believers kept on asking God for Peter’s life.
On the last night, the night before the trial, the answer came. An angel stood in the cell, and light filled it. The chains fell from Peter’s hands. The iron gate into the city swung open by itself. Peter found himself alone in a dark street, free.
In Volume 2 we stood with Rhoda at the gate of Mary’s house and laughed at the joy of that night. Here we look more closely at the praying that came before the knock, and at the questions it leaves us with.
“Without letup”
The phrase Luke uses means praying with intensity, stretched out toward God. R. A. Torrey, the American Bible teacher, studied the word carefully:
“The word means literally “stretched-out-ed-ly.” It is a pictorial word, and wonderfully expressive. It represents the soul on a stretch of earnest and intense desire.”
R. A. Torrey, How to Pray
This was not a polite prayer at the end of a meeting. It was the church leaning its whole weight on God.
How long did they pray? Luke does not tell us exactly. Peter was arrested during the feast, which lasted seven days, and was held until it ended. So the church may have prayed for a week or more. At least on the last night, many of them were still awake and praying together at Mary’s house, very late.
That tells us something important. The church did not pray once and then go home. Night after night, nothing seemed to change. Peter was still in chains. The trial was coming closer. And they kept on.
What about James?
Here we must be honest. If the church prayed for Peter with such passion, did it not also pray for James? Luke does not say. But it is hard to imagine that these believers, who prayed about everything, were silent while one of the apostles sat in Herod’s prison. They loved James as much as they loved Peter.
Yet James died, and Peter walked free.
Some have tried to explain this simply: the church must have prayed for Peter but not for James, or prayed harder the second time. The Bible gives us no such explanation, and we should not invent one. It would place a heavy and unfair burden on the believers who buried James. The truth is that we do not know why God rescued one apostle and not the other.
What we do know is this. Jesus Himself had told James this would happen. Years before, James and his brother had asked for places of honor in His kingdom. Jesus answered, “The cup I drink, you will drink” (Mark 10:39). James’s death was not a mistake that God failed to stop. It was a cup he shared with his Lord.
The letter to the Hebrews describes the same mystery. Some of God’s people, by faith, “got away from the sword’s edge,” while others “were stoned, sawn in two, cut down by the sword” (Hebrews 11:34-37). Both groups were faithful. Both were loved. The difference lay in the purposes of God, not in the quality of their faith. Even Peter’s rescue was not forever. Jesus had told him that one day he too would die for Him (John 21:18-19), and the early church remembered that he did.
Thomas Watson, the English Puritan, wrote words that help us hold this:
“Those whom God intends to save from hell, he does not save from the cross.”
Thomas Watson, The Lord’s Prayer
So the church that prayed for Peter did not pray because it was sure of the answer. It prayed because it trusted the God who answers, even when His answers are hard to understand.
“You have lost your mind!”
There is one more surprise in this story. When Rhoda ran in to say that Peter was at the gate, the praying believers did not believe her. “You have lost your mind!” they said. Then, “It is his angel” (Acts 12:15). They had been asking God for this very thing, and when it came, it seemed impossible.
Perhaps James’s death had taught them to expect the worst. Perhaps their faith was tired after many nights. Whatever the reason, their prayers were stronger than their expectations. And God answered them anyway.
This should comfort us. God did not wait for the church to have perfect faith. He heard prayers offered by people who were grieving, frightened and unsure. Watson put it memorably:
“The angel fetched Peter out of prison, but it was prayer fetched the angel.”
Thomas Watson, All Things for Good
Luke ends the chapter with Herod himself. Not long afterward, as the crowds praised him as a god, he was struck down and died. Then Luke adds: “But the word of God went on growing and spreading” (Acts 12:24). The king who killed James was gone. The church that prayed was still there.
Three key insights
- The church’s first and strongest response to danger is prayer. The believers in Jerusalem had no power to free Peter. They did what they could do, and it turned out to be the most powerful thing of all.
- God’s different answers are not a measure of our faith. James died and Peter lived, and Scripture does not blame the church for either. We may pray for two people with the same love and see God answer differently. His ways are higher than ours.
- God answers even prayers mixed with doubt. The believers could hardly believe their prayer had been answered. God did not wait for their faith to be perfect. Our weak, tired prayers still reach Him.
For us today
Around the world today, believers are in prison for their faith. In some countries, pastors are held for years without trial. Churches in safer places can do what the church in Jerusalem did: pray earnestly, together, by name, without letup. Some of those prisoners will be released. Some will not. We pray for both, and we leave the outcome with God.
Many of us also know the pain of the “James” prayers. We prayed for a mother with cancer, and she died. We prayed for a friend, and another friend with the same illness was healed instead. It is right to bring that sorrow to God honestly. The Bible does not hide it. James gets only one verse in Acts, but he is not forgotten by God.
And some of us need the lesson of Mary’s house. We have prayed so long that we have stopped expecting anything. When God answers, we may be the last to believe it. Keep praying anyway. God hears tired prayers too.
Try this
This week, pray like the church in Jerusalem.
- Pray for a prisoner. Learn the name of one Christian imprisoned for their faith today, and pray for them by name every day this week.
- Pray with others. Gather two or three believers, in a home if you can, and spend time praying together for someone in serious trouble.
- Tell God about your “James.” If there is a prayer that God answered differently than you hoped, tell Him honestly how you feel. Then ask Him for the grace to trust Him.
- Watch for the knock. Write down what you are asking God for, and check your list each evening. Be ready to be surprised.
A closing prayer
Lord God, You saw James die, and You opened the prison for Peter. I do not understand all Your ways, but I trust You. Teach me to pray as Your church prayed in Jerusalem, with my whole heart and without letup. I pray for my brothers and sisters in prison for Your name today. Strengthen them, comfort them, and set them free if it is Your will. When my faith is tired, hear my prayers anyway, and when You answer, give me the joy to believe it. In Jesus’ name. Amen.
Questions for reflection
- Why do you think the believers found it so hard to believe that their prayer had been answered?
- How do you respond when God answers prayers for two people differently?
- Who could you pray for “without letup” this week, the way the church prayed for Peter?
Read more on Ochorus
- R. A. Torrey, How to Pray, especially “Praying unto God”
- Thomas Watson, All Things for Good, especially “The best things work for good to the godly”
- E. M. Bounds, The Possibilities of Prayer, especially “Prayer Miracles”