A Catena on John
John 19

Chapter 20 · 28 min read · 36 min listen

John 19

Previously: Judas leads soldiers to arrest Jesus in a garden, and Peter, who strikes with a sword, then denies Jesus three times. Jesus is questioned by Annas and then brought before Pilate, and declares that the kingdom of Jesus does not come from this world. The crowd asks for Barabbas instead. With John Chrysostom, Augustine, Cyril of Alexandria and 6 more.

In this chapter

Pilate has Jesus flogged and, under pressure from the crowd, hands Jesus over to be crucified as "the King of the Jews". From the cross Jesus entrusts Mary to the disciple Jesus loved, says, "It is finished," and dies; Joseph of Arimathea and Nicodemus bury the body. With Augustine, Cyril of Alexandria, John Calvin and 5 more.

The soldiers mock Jesus

Then Pilate took Jesus and had him flogged. The soldiers wove a crown out of thorns and set it on his head, and they dressed him in a purple robe.

— John 19:1–2

Augustine · Tractates on John

On the Jews crying out that they did not wish Jesus to be released unto them at the passover, but Barabbas the robber; not the Saviour, but the murderer; not the Giver of life, but the destroyer,—“then Pilate took Jesus and scourged Him.” We must believe that Pilate acted thus for no other reason than that the Jews, glutted with the injuries done to Him, might consider themselves satisfied, and desist from madly pursuing Him even unto death. With a similar intention was it that, as governor, he also permitted his cohort to do what follows, or even perhaps ordered them, although the evangelist is silent on the subject. For he tells us what the soldiers did thereafter, but not that Pilate ordered it. “And the soldiers,” he says, “platted a crown of thorns, and put it on His head, and they clothed Him with a purple robe. And they came to Him and said, Hail, King of the Jews! And they smote Him with their hands.” Thus were fulfilled the very things which Christ had foretold of Himself; thus were the martyrs moulded for the endurance of all that their persecutors should be pleased to inflict; thus, by concealing for a time the terror of His power, He commended to us the prior imitation of His patience; thus the kingdom which was not of this world overcame that proud world, not by the ferocity of fighting, but by the humility of suffering; and thus the grain of corn that was yet to be multiplied was sown amid the horrors of shame, that it might come to fruition amid the wonders of glory.

Again and again they came up to him and said, “Hail, King of the Jews!” and struck him in the face.

— John 19:3

B. F. Westcott · The Gospel According to St. John

According to the best authorities, And they came unto Him and said. This vivid detail does not occur in the narratives of the parallel incident. The imperfect... gives the picture of the separate formal acts of homage rendered by the soldiers in succession.

Hail, King of the Jews] The words are evidently a mocking echo of what they had heard. Like Pilate, they ridicule the people no less than the Lord.

smote him...] Some old versions add “on the face.” This is probably the true idea. The savage blow took the place of the kiss of homage. Comp. xviii. 22.

Pilate went outside again and said to them, “Look, I am bringing him out to you, so that you may know that I find no case against him.” So Jesus came outside, still wearing the thorny crown and the purple robe. Pilate said to them, “Look, here is the man!”

— John 19:4–5

Matthew Henry · Commentary on the Whole Bible

But some of the Greek copies, and the generality of the translators, supply it as we do, Pilate saith unto them, with a design to appease them, Behold the man; not so much to move their pity, Behold a man worthy your compassion, as to silence their jealousies, Behold a man not worthy your suspicion, a man from whom you can henceforth fear no danger; his crown is profaned, and cast to the ground, and now all mankind will make a jest of him. The word however is very affecting: Behold the man. It is good for every one of us, with an eye of faith, to behold the man Christ Jesus in his sufferings. Behold this king with the crown wherewith his mother crowned him, the crown of thorns, Cant. iii. 11. “Behold him, and be suitably affected with the sight. Behold him, and mourn because of him. Behold him, and love him; be still looking unto Jesus.”

When the chief priests and the temple police saw him, they shouted, “Crucify! Crucify!” Pilate told them, “Take him yourselves and crucify him. I find no case against him.” The Jewish leaders replied, “We have a law, and by that law he must die, because he made himself the Son of God.”

— John 19:6–7

John Calvin · Commentary on John

On the other hand, we may easily find a reply to wicked men, who falsely and improperly allege the testimony of Scripture, and the principles which they draw from it, to support their bad designs; just as the Papists, when they extol in lofty terms the authority of the Church, bring forward nothing about which all the children of God are not agreed. They maintain that the Church is the mother of believers, that she is the pillar of truth, that she ought to be heard, that she is guided by the Holy Spirit. All this we ought to admit, but when they wish to appropriate to themselves all the authority that is due to the Church, they wickedly, and with sacrilegious presumption, seize what does not at all belong to them. For we must inquire into the grounds of what they assume as true, that they deserve the title of The Church; and here they utterly fail. In like manner, when they exercise furious cruelty against all the godly, they do so on this pretence, that they have been ordained to defend the faith and peace of the Church. But when we examine the matter more closely, we plainly see that there is nothing which they have less at heart than the defense of true doctrine, that nothing affects them less than a care about peace and harmony, but that they only fight to uphold their own tyranny. They who are satisfied with general principles, and do not attend to the circumstances, imagine that the Papists do right in attacking us; but the investigation of the matter quickly dissipates that smoke by which they deceive the simple.

When Pilate heard this, he was even more afraid. He went back inside the headquarters and said to Jesus, “Where do you come from?” But Jesus gave him no answer.

— John 19:8–9

J. C. Ryle · Expository Thoughts on John

This means, that, on hearing this fresh charge of blasphemy, Pilate retired again from the outside of the palace into the inner part, where he had before conversed with our Lord, once more leaving the Jews outside. This new charge was so serious that he did not care to enter into it publicly, and preferred examining our Lord about it privately.

[And saith... Whence art Thou?] This question I think can admit of only one meaning. It meant, —“Who art Thou? What art Thou? Art Thou from heaven? Art Thou one of the gods come down to earth, of whom I have heard the priests talk? What is Thy real nature and history? If Thou art some superior being, more than a common man, tell me plainly, that I may know how to deal with Thy case. Tell me privately, while these Jews are not present, that I may know what line to take up with Thine enemies.”— We may well believe that Pilate caught at the secret hope that Jesus might tell him something about Himself, which would enable Him to make a firm stand and deliver Him from the Jews. In this hope, again, the Roman Governor was destined to be disappointed.

So Pilate said to him, “Are you refusing to speak to me?” Do you not know that I have authority to set you free and authority to crucify you?

— John 19:10

J. A. Bengel · Gnomon of the New Testament

unto me) This was said with severity.... no power at all) either to crucify or to let go, or any other power.... given) It had been given to Pilate to have power.... therefore) Because thou hast not known (dost not know) Me at all.... he who hath delivered Me to thee) This was Caiaphas. Pilate, when he heard mention, however, made of the Son of God, was afraid: Caiaphas, when he had heard from the Lord Himself that He was the Son of God, called Him a blasphemer, and judicially pronounced Him “guilty of death” [Matt. xxvi. 65, 66].

Jesus answered, “You would have no authority over me at all unless it had been given to you from above. That is why the one who handed me over to you carries the greater sin.”

— John 19:11

John Wesley · Explanatory Notes

Thou couldst have no power over me — For I have done nothing to expose me to the power of any magistrate. Therefore he that delivered me to thee, namely, Caiaphas, knowing this, is more blamable than thou.

From then on Pilate tried to set him free, but the Jewish leaders shouted, “If you let this man go, you are no friend of Caesar. Anyone who claims to be a king is setting himself against Caesar.” When Pilate heard this, he brought Jesus outside and took his seat on the judgment seat at the place known as the Stone Pavement, in Hebrew Gabbatha. It was the day of Preparation of the Passover, about noon. Pilate said to the Jewish leaders, “Look, here is your King!” They shouted back, “Away with him! Away with him! Crucify him!” Pilate said to them, “Shall I crucify your King?” The chief priests replied, “We have no king but Caesar.”

— John 19:12–15

Cyril of Alexandria · Commentary on John

They reiterate their old cry with the same fury, and desisted not from their lust for blood, and were not softened at all by the insults He had endured, nor inclined to clemency by the outrages inflicted upon Him; but were rather goaded to a greater pitch of fury, and intreat that He Who had raised the dead in their midst, and shown Himself the worker of such marvels, should be crucified; at which Pilate was sore amazed, seeing that they declared with such vehemence, that He, Who had acquired such eminence among them as to be deemed the Son of God, and King, was not merely worthy of death, but that He deserved so cruel a fate, for crucifixion is the worst of deaths. The judge, therefore, makes their outcry a charge and reproach against them, that they should be desirous that He should be crucified, Who had excited so great admiration by deeds which were so pre-eminent as to transcend anything on earth. For what is there that is equal to what does not fall short of the Son of God, and King?

The crucifixion

Then Pilate handed him over to them to be crucified. So they took charge of Jesus.

— John 19:16

Cyril of Alexandria · Commentary on John

Pilate henceforward permits the Jews, in their unbridled resentment, to run to all lengths in lawlessness; and, divesting himself of the power due unto a judge, suffers their uncontrolled passions at length to take their course unreproved, in allowing them to crucify One Who was wholly guiltless, and Who received this monstrous condemnation merely because He said He was the Son of God. One must lay the whole guilt of the impious crime at the door of the Jews; and rightly and justly, I think, accuse them of being the prime movers in the act, for with them originated this impiety against Christ. Yet we cannot acquit Pilate of complicity in their iniquity; for he shared their responsibility, inasmuch as when he might have delivered and rescued Him from the madness of His murderers, he did not merely refrain from releasing Him, but even gave Him up to them for the very purpose, that they might crucify Him.

Carrying the cross by himself, he went out to what is called the Place of the Skull (in Hebrew, Golgotha). There they crucified him, along with two others, one on each side and Jesus in the middle.

— John 19:17–18

J. C. Ryle · Expository Thoughts on John

This famous mode of execution is so well known to every one that little need be said of it. The common mode of inflicting it, in all probability, was to strip the criminal, — to lay him on the cross on his back, — to nail his hands to the two extremities of the cross-piece, or fork of the cross, — to nail his feet to the upright piece, or principal stem of the cross, — then to raise the cross on end, and drop it into a hole prepared for it, — and then to leave the sufferer to a lingering and painful death. It was a death which combined the maximum of pain with the least immediate destruction of life. The agony of having nails driven through parts so full of nerves and sinews as the hands and feet, must have been intense. Yet wounds of the hands and feet are not mortal, and do not injure any great leading blood-vessel. Hence a crucified person, even in an eastern climate, exposed to the sun, might live two or three days, enduring extreme pain, without being relieved by death, if he was naturally a very strong man and in vigorous health. This is what we must remember our blessed Lord went through, when we read “they crucified Him.” To a sensitive, delicate-minded person, it is hard to imagine any capital punishment more distressing. This is what Jesus endured willingly for us sinners. Hanging, as it were, between earth and heaven. He exactly filled the type of the brazen serpent, which Moses lifted up in the wilderness. (John iii. 14.)

Pilate also wrote a notice and had it placed on the cross. The wording was: “Jesus of Nazareth, the King of the Jews.” Many of the Jews of Jerusalem read this notice, since the spot where Jesus was crucified was close to the city. The notice was in Hebrew, Latin and Greek.

— John 19:19–20

Matthew Henry · Commentary on the Whole Bible

God so ordering it that this should be written in the three then most known tongues, it was intimated thereby that Jesus Christ should be a Saviour to all nations, and not to the Jews only; and also that every nation should hear in their own tongue the wonderful works of the Redeemer. Hebrew, Greek, and Latin, were the vulgar languages at that time in this part of the world; so that this is so far from intimating (as the Papists would have it) that the scripture is still to be retained in these three languages, that on the contrary it teaches us that the knowledge of Christ ought to be diffused throughout every nation in their own tongue, as the proper vehicle of it, that people may converse as freely with the scriptures as they do with their neighbours.

The chief priests of the Jews objected. “Do not write ‘The King of the Jews,’” they told Pilate. “Write that this man said, ‘I am King of the Jews.’” Pilate answered, “What I have written, I have written.” When the soldiers had crucified Jesus, they took his clothes and divided them into four shares, one share for each soldier. They also took his tunic. The tunic was seamless, woven in a single piece from top to bottom.

— John 19:21–23

John Calvin · Commentary on John

Then the soldiers. The other Evangelists also mention the parting of Christ’s garments among the soldiers, (Matthew 27:35; Mark 15:24; Luke 23:34.) There were four soldiers who parted among themselves all his garments, except the coat, which, being without seam could not be divided, and therefore they cast lots on it. To fix our minds on the contemplation of the purpose of God, the Evangelists remind us that, in this occurrence also, there was a fulfillment of Scripture. It may be thought, however, that the passage, which they quote from Psalm 22:18, is inappropriately applied to the subject in hand; for, though David complains in it that he was exposed as a prey to his enemies, he makes use of the word garments to denote metaphorically all his property; as if he had said, in a single word, that “he had been stripped naked and bare by wicked men;” and, when the Evangelists disregard the figure, they depart from the natural meaning of the passage. But we ought to remember, in the first place, that the psalm ought not to be restricted to David, as is evident from many parts of it, and especially from a clause in which it is written, I will proclaim thy name among the Gentiles, (Psalm 22:22) which must be explained as referring to Christ. We need not wonder, therefore, if that which was faintly shadowed out in David is beheld in Christ with all that superior clearness which the truth ought to have, as compared with the figurative representation of it.

So they said to each other, “Let us not tear it. Let us cast lots for it and see who gets it.” This was so that the Scripture would be fulfilled that says, “They shared out my garments among themselves, and for my clothing they cast lots.” That is what the soldiers did.

— John 19:24

Jesus’s mother at the cross

Meanwhile, near the cross of Jesus stood his mother, her sister, Mary the wife of Clopas, and Mary Magdalene. Jesus saw his mother there, and near her the disciple whom he loved. He said to his mother, “Woman, look, here is your son.”

— John 19:25–26

John Calvin · Commentary on John

Woman, behold thy son! As if he had said, “Henceforth I shall not be an inhabitant of the earth, so as to have it in my power to discharge to thee the duties of a son; and, therefore, I put this man in my room, that he may perform my office.” The same thing is meant, when he says to John,

Behold thy mother! For by these words he charges him to treat her as a mother, and to take as much care of her as if she had been his own mother.

In refraining from mentioning his mother’s name and in simply calling her Woman! some think that he did so, in order not to pierce her heart with a deeper wound. I do not object to this view; but there is another conjecture which is equally probable, that Christ intended to show that, after having completed the course of human life, he lays down the condition in which he had lived, and enters into the heavenly kingdom, where he will exercise dominion over angels and men; for we know that Christ was always accustomed to guard believers against looking at the flesh, and it was especially necessary that this should be done at his death.

Then he said to the disciple, “Look, here is your mother.” From that time on the disciple took her into his own home.

— John 19:27

Augustine · Tractates on John

A passage, therefore, of a moral character is here inserted. The good Teacher does what He thereby reminds us ought to be done, and by His own example instructed His disciples that care for their parents ought to be a matter of concern to pious children: as if that tree to which the members of the dying One were affixed were the very chair of office from which the Master was imparting instruction. From this wholesome doctrine it was that the Apostle Paul had learned what he taught in turn, when he said, “But if any provide not for his own, and especially for those of his own house, he hath denied the faith, and is worse than an infidel.” And what are so much home concerns to any one, as parents to children, or children to parents? Of this most wholesome precept, therefore, the very Master of the saints set the example from Himself, when, not as God for the hand-maid whom He had created and governed, but as a man for the mother, of whom He had been created, and whom He was now leaving behind, He provided in some measure another son in place of Himself. And why He did so, He indicates in the words that follow: for the evangelist says, “And from that hour the disciple took her unto his own,” speaking of himself. In this way, indeed, he usually refers to himself as the disciple whom Jesus loved: who certainly loved them all, but him beyond the others, and with a closer familiarity, so that He even made him lean upon His bosom at supper; in order, I believe, in this way to commend the more highly the divine excellence of this very gospel, which He was thereafter to preach through his instrumentality.

The death of Jesus

After this, Jesus knew that everything had now been finished. So that the Scripture would be completed, he said, “I am thirsty.”

— John 19:28

Cyril of Alexandria · Commentary on John

When the iniquity of the Jews had fully wrought the impious crime against Christ, and when there was nothing left wanting to the perfect satisfaction of their savage cruelty, the flesh, at the last extremity, felt a natural craving, for it was parched by the various acts of outrage, and felt thirst. For pain is very apt to provoke thirst, spending the natural moisture of the body in excessive inward heat, and burning the inward parts with the pangs of inflammation. It would have been easy for the Word, the Almighty God, to have released His Flesh from this torment; but, just as He willingly underwent His other sufferings, so He bore this also of His own Will. Then He sought to drink; but so pitiless and far removed from the love of God were they, that, instead of liquid to quench His thirst, they gave Him something to aggravate it, and, in rendering the very service of love, committed a further act of impiety. For, in acceding at all to His request, were they not assuming the appearance of affection? But it was impossible that the inspired Scripture should ever lie, which put into the mouth of the Saviour these words concerning them: They gave Me gall to eat, and when I was athirst, they gave Me vinegar to drink.

A jar full of sour wine stood there. So they put a sponge soaked in the sour wine on a stalk of hyssop and raised it to his lips.

— John 19:29

Matthew Henry · Commentary on the Whole Bible

See how little respect his persecutors showed to him (v. 29): There was set a vessel full of vinegar, probably according to the custom at all executions of this nature; or, as others think, it was now set designedly for an abuse to Christ, instead of the cup of wine which they used to give to those that were ready to perish; with this they filled a sponge, for they would not allow him a cup, and they put it upon hyssop, a hyssop-stalk, and with this heaved it to his mouth; hyssopo perithentes—they stuck it round with hyssop; so it may be taken; or, as others, they mingled it with hyssop-water, and this they gave him to drink when he was thirsty; a drop of water would have cooled his tongue better than a draught of vinegar: yet this he submitted to for us. We had taken the sour grapes, and thus his teeth were set on edge; we had forfeited all comforts and refreshments, and therefore they were withheld from him. When heaven denied him a beam of light earth denied him a drop of water, and put vinegar in the room of it.

When Jesus had taken the sour wine, he said, “It is finished.” Then he bowed his head and handed over his spirit.

— John 19:30

Jesus’s side is pierced

It was the day of Preparation, and the Jewish leaders did not want the bodies to stay on the crosses over the Sabbath, because that Sabbath was a day of special importance. So they asked Pilate to have the men’s legs broken and the bodies removed.

— John 19:31

Cyril of Alexandria · Commentary on John

It is not with the motive of testifying to the reverence for holy days felt by men inured to shed blood with brutal ferocity, and found guilty of so monstrous an iniquity, that the blessed Evangelist says this; but rather from the wish to show that, in their gross stupidity, they committed that folly of which Christ spoke. For they strained out the gnat while they swallowed the camel; for they are found to reckon as of no account at all the most outrageous and awful of all crimes against God, while they exercised the greatest diligence with reference to the most paltry and insignificant matters, showing their folly in either case. The proof of this is not far to seek. For, behold, in the very act of putting Christ to death, they put great store on the respect due to the Sabbath; and, while they insulted the Lawgiver by outrages which surpass description, they parade their reverence of the Law; and, as that Sabbath was a high day, they affect to pay honour to it——the very men who destroyed the Lord of the high day; and they ask a favour, which well suited their cruel spirit. For they besought Pilate that their legs might be broken, wishing to embitter, by this last intolerable outrage, the pangs of approaching death, to those who were already in agony.

J. C. Ryle · Expository Thoughts on John

The “Jews” in this verse, as in many other places in St. John’s Gospel, can only mean the chief priests and leaders of the nation at Jerusalem; the same men who had pressed on Pilate our Lord’s crucifixion,— Annas, Caiaphas, and their companions.

The “preparation” means the day preceding the passover sabbath. That sabbath being pre-eminently a “high day,” or, to render the Greek literally, a “great” day in the year, the Friday, or day preceding it, was devoted to special preparations. Hence the day went by the name of “the preparation of the sabbath.” The expression makes it certain that Jesus was crucified on a Friday. The Jews saw clearly that, unless they took active measures to prevent it, the body of our Lord would remain all night hanging on the tree of the cross, the law would be broken (Deut. xxi. 23), and a dead body would hang throughout the sabbath in full view of the temple, and close by the city walls. Therefore they made haste to have Him taken down from the cross and buried.

So the soldiers came. They broke the first man’s legs, and then the legs of the other man crucified with Jesus. But when they reached Jesus, they saw that he had already died. So they did not break his legs. One of the soldiers, however, drove a spear into his side, and at once blood and water flowed out.

— John 19:32–34

Matthew Henry · Commentary on the Whole Bible

[1.] To give an evidence of the truth of his death, in order to the proof of his resurrection. If he was only in a trance or swoon, his resurrection was a sham; but, by this experiment, he was certainly dead, for this spear broke up the very fountains of life, and, according to all the law and course of nature, it was impossible a human body should survive such a wound as this in the vitals, and such an evacuation thence.

The one who saw this has testified to it, and his testimony is true. He knows that what he says is true, and he has told it so that you also may believe. These things took place so that the Scripture would be fulfilled: “Not one bone of his will be broken.” And another passage of Scripture also says, “They will look at the one they pierced.”

— John 19:35–37

John Calvin · Commentary on John

A question now arises as to this passage taken from the prophet, Does God promise to the Jews repentance to salvation, or, does he threaten that he will come as an avenger? For my own part, when I closely examine the passage, I think that it includes both; namely, that out of a worthless and unprincipled nation God will gather a remnant for salvation, and that, by his dreadful vengeance, he will show to despisers who it is with whom they have to do; for we know that they were wont to treat the prophets as insolently as if the prophets had told nothing but fables, and had received no commission from God. God declares that they will not pass unpunished, for he will at length maintain his cause.

The burial of Jesus

After this, Joseph of Arimathea, a disciple of Jesus who had kept it hidden because he feared the Jewish leaders, asked Pilate for permission to take away the body of Jesus, and Pilate granted it. So Joseph came and took his body away.

— John 19:38

Matthew Henry · Commentary on the Whole Bible

His disciples were gone; if nobody appeared, the Jews or soldiers would bury him with the thieves; therefore God raised up this gentleman to interpose in it, that the scripture might be fulfilled, and the decorum owing to his approaching resurrection maintained. Note, When God has work to do he can find out such as are proper to do it, and embolden them for it. Observe it as an instance of the humiliation of Christ, that his dead body lay at the mercy of a heathen judge, and must be begged before it could be buried, and also that Joseph would not take the body of Christ till he had asked and obtained leave of the governor; for in those things wherein the power of the magistrate is concerned we must ever pay a deference to that power, and peaceably submit to it.

Nicodemus came too, the man who had first come to Jesus at night. He brought a mixture of myrrh and aloes weighing about 70 pounds.

— John 19:39

Cyril of Alexandria · Commentary on John

He says that this disciple was not alone in taking counsel wisely, as well as in fervent zeal, to go to dress the sacred Body for burial, but he makes mention of a second along with the first. This was Nicodemus, who completed the body of testimony to the event that is respected by the Law. For, says the Law: In the mouth of two or three witnesses shall every word be established. The men who laid Jesus in the tomb were two in number, Joseph and Nicodemus; men who received the faith inwardly in their hearts, but were still scared by a foolish fear, and did not yet prefer to the honour and glory of the world that which is of God. For then they would have dismissed all fear of the Jews, and, paying slight heed to any danger from that quarter, would have indulged their faith fearlessly and freely, and thus have proved themselves holy, and good keepers of the commandment of our Saviour.

They took Jesus’s body and wrapped it with the spices in linen cloths, which is how the Jews prepare a body for burial. There was a garden at the place where he had been crucified, and in that garden there was a new tomb where no one had ever been laid.

— John 19:40–41

J. C. Ryle · Expository Thoughts on John

This verse tells us the place where our Lord was buried. It was in “a garden” close to the spot called Golgotha, where He was crucified. This fact alone seems to dispose of the theory, that the “place of a skull” meant a place where the skeletons and bones of executed criminals were lying about! Reason and common-sense point out, that, even if there were no argument against the theory from the Jewish customs about bones, it is very unlikely that “a garden” would have been near such a loathsome place. Golgotha could hardly be a place of execution, or a place where criminals were frequently crucified, if there was a garden near! The pictures that commonly represent the scene of the crucifixion as a bleak desolate-looking rocky hill, are manifestly quite incorrect. It was a place near to which, or where “there was a garden.”

The curious coincidence that the fall of the first Adam, the agony, the cross, and the sepulchre of the second Adam, were all alike connected with a garden, can hardly fail to strike a reflecting mind.

The tomb was close at hand, and it was the Jewish day of Preparation, so they laid Jesus there.

— John 19:42

Previous Next