Chapter 16 · 9 min read · 12 min listen
A Heart Without Words
“People, rely on Him in every season; empty your hearts out before Him. God is our shelter.” (Psalm 62:8)
On 12 November 1660, a small group of believers met in a farmhouse at Lower Samsell, near the village of Harlington in the English county of Bedfordshire. They had invited a preacher named John Bunyan. He was a tinker, a man who traveled from village to village mending pots and pans. He had little schooling, but for some years he had been preaching in the villages around Bedford.
That day a friend warned him that a warrant was out for his arrest. He could have slipped away. But he asked himself what the young believers would think if their preacher ran, so he stayed and began the meeting. Bunyan later wrote that when the constable came in, he found them “only with our Bibles in our hands, ready to speak and hear the Word of God.” They had already begun in prayer.
England had a king again, and old laws were being used against church meetings held outside the parish church. In January 1661 Bunyan stood before the judges in Bedford. Bunyan wrote down the conversation himself, and his account was printed long after his death.
The chief judge, Justice Keelin, asked why he did not go to the parish church. Bunyan said he did not find it commanded in the Word of God.
“We were commanded to pray,” said the judge.
“But not by the Common Prayer Book,” Bunyan answered. He meant the official book of prayers that every parish was required to use.
“How then?”
“With the Spirit,” said Bunyan, and he quoted Paul’s words about praying with the Spirit and with the understanding (1 Corinthians 14:15).
Then another judge asked him a question: “What do you count prayer? Do you think it is to say a few words over before or among a people?”
Bunyan’s answer is one of the best short descriptions of prayer ever given in a courtroom. “No, not so; for men might have many elegant, or excellent words, and yet not pray at all; but when a man prayeth, he doth, through a sense of those things which he wants, which sense is begotten by the Spirit, pour out his heart before God through Christ; though his words be not so many and so excellent as others are.”
The judges agreed: “That was true.” But they sent him back to prison. Bunyan would stay there, with a few short breaks, for twelve years.
Who he was
John Bunyan was born in 1628 in Elstow, near Bedford, the son of a tinker. At sixteen he became a soldier in the civil war. Afterward he married a young woman who brought two Christian books into their poor home. Their first child, Mary, born in 1650, was blind.
For several years Bunyan went through a terrible spiritual struggle. He tells the whole story in Grace Abounding to the Chief of Sinners. He was tormented by fear that he had committed a sin God would never forgive. Some days it seemed impossible even to pray. Yet he would not stop coming to Christ:
“These places did pinch me very sore; yet, my case being desperate, I thought with myself I can but die; and if it must be so, it shall once be said, that such an one died at the foot of Christ in prayer.”
John Bunyan, Grace Abounding to the Chief of Sinners
At last God gave him peace through the righteousness of Christ. He joined a small church in Bedford, and soon the members asked him to preach. His first wife died in 1658, and a year later he married a young woman named Elizabeth, who bravely cared for his four children while he was in prison. In prison he made laces to earn a little money for his family, and he wrote. Grace Abounding was written there, and later he began his most famous book, The Pilgrim’s Progress. He was set free in 1672, became the pastor of the church in Bedford, and died in London in 1688.
His hardest pain in prison was his family, especially his blind daughter:
“Poor child! thought I, what sorrow art thou like to have for thy portion in this world! Thou must be beaten, must beg, suffer hunger, cold, nakedness, and a thousand calamities, though I cannot now endure the wind should blow upon thee. But yet recalling myself, thought I, I must venture you all with God, though it goeth to the quick to leave you.”
John Bunyan, Grace Abounding to the Chief of Sinners
(“It goeth to the quick” means it cuts deep, to the most painful place.) Mary died some years before her father.
What he taught about prayer
In 1662, in his prison cell, Bunyan wrote a small book on prayer. It is usually called I Will Pray with the Spirit, after the words of Paul in 1 Corinthians 14:15. In it he gave this definition: “Prayer is a sincere, sensible, affectionate pouring out of the heart or soul to God, through Christ, in the strength and assistance of the Holy Spirit.” “Sincere” means honest, “sensible” means truly feeling our need, and “affectionate” means full of strong desire.
The heart of his teaching is the picture in our verse. “Empty your hearts out before Him,” says the psalmist (Psalm 62:8). Bunyan quoted this psalm, with others like it, and said that pouring out the soul means that in prayer “there goeth the very life and whole strength to God.” Hannah prayed this way. She said, “I have been pouring out my soul before the LORD” (1 Samuel 1:15).
Bunyan knew that a heart full of need often cannot find the right words. That does not stop the prayer, for, as we saw with Sibbes in chapter 13, God hears the Spirit’s groans within us. Bunyan put it simply: “The best prayers have often more groans than words.” A collection of his sayings, printed after his death, puts it in a line that many have remembered: “When thou prayest, rather let thy hearts be without words, than thy words without a heart.”
We should be fair here. Bunyan refused to use the Book of Common Prayer, and he argued against it sharply, because the law was forcing it on everyone. Many faithful Christians, then and now, have prayed from that book with all their hearts, as we saw in chapter 4. Even in court Bunyan said that those who wanted to use it should have their liberty. His point is one that every Christian can share: words, whether written or spoken freely, are only prayer when the heart is in them.
Three key insights
- Prayer is pouring out the heart to God, not putting on a show of fine words. God does not count our words or grade our speech. He looks for honest need, real desire and trust in Christ, even when the words are few and plain.
- Even in despair, the safest place to be is at the feet of Christ in prayer. When Bunyan felt that heaven was shut against him, he decided that if he died, he would die praying. The darkest feelings are not a reason to stop coming to Him.
- A prison can take away our freedom, but it cannot shut the door between us and God. Bunyan lost twelve years and could not protect his family, yet no jailer could stop his prayers. In his cell he poured out his heart, and God used those years to bless the whole church.
For us today
Bunyan’s story is the story of many believers today. In some countries Christians are arrested for meeting in homes, just as he was. Pastors sit in prison while their families struggle to find food, and parents carry the weight of children with special needs. Bunyan shows them that a prison cell can still be a place of prayer.
His teaching also frees ordinary believers. Many people think they cannot pray because they do not have fine words. Some cannot read. Some are too tired or too sad to put a sentence together. Bunyan says: come anyway. Empty your heart before God. A groan, a sigh or a few broken words offered through Christ are true prayer.
In The Pilgrim’s Progress, when Christian walks through the dark valley and his sword is no use against the flames, he takes up “another weapon, called All-prayer,” and cries, “O Lord, I beseech thee, deliver my soul.” That weapon is in the hands of every believer, everywhere.
Try this
This week, practice pouring out your heart to God.
- Tell Him everything. Find a quiet place, even a corner or a walk outside, and tell God honestly what is in your heart, as Psalm 62:8 invites you to do.
- Speak plainly. Pray this week without any fine words, as you would talk to someone you trust, and notice that God does not need them.
- Check your heart, not only your words. Before you pray the Lord’s Prayer or a familiar prayer, stop and ask God to put your heart into it.
- Entrust someone you cannot protect. Like Bunyan with his blind daughter, name one person you love but cannot keep safe, and place them in God’s hands.
A closing prayer
Father, You invite me to rely on You in every season and to empty out my heart before You. Here is my heart, with all its fears, needs and sins. I come to You through Jesus Christ, Your Son, who opened the way. Thank You for Your servant John Bunyan, who prayed in prison and taught plain people to pray. When I have no words, let Your Spirit pray within me. When I feel shut out, keep me at the feet of Christ. Take care of the people I love when I cannot protect them. Strengthen every believer in prison for Your name, and comfort their families. Let my words never be without a heart, and let my heart always find its shelter in You. Amen.
Questions for reflection
- Bunyan told the judges that people might use many excellent words “and yet not pray at all.” When are you most in danger of praying with words but not with your heart?
- Have you ever felt too discouraged to pray? What does Bunyan’s decision to die “at the foot of Christ in prayer” teach you?
- Bunyan placed his blind daughter in God’s hands when he could not care for her. Who do you need to entrust to God in prayer today?
Read more on Ochorus
- John Bunyan, Grace Abounding to the Chief of Sinners, especially “A Brief Account of the Author’s Imprisonment”
- John Bunyan, The Pilgrim’s Progress, especially “The Fourth Stage”
- Ochorus Originals, The Key Teachings of John Bunyan, especially “The Preacher in Bedford Gaol”